Sanjaya Malakar — It’s Over.

Wednesday, April 18, 2007, 10:03 PM | American Idol 6, Sanjaya Malakar

Sanjaya Malakar

The greatest run in American Idol history has ended.

Here he is, Sanjaya Malakar, just a normal kid with a background so typical of many youths today — a family with divorced parents, living day to day in an increasingly difficult world — thrust into the spotlight on the most popular show on Earth — and he shines. He became the most talked about Idol in the 6-year history of the show, and he held himself with dignity in the face of relentless adversity. There is so much we can learn from how Sanjaya handled himself on this show.

It pains me to think that there are so many of you out there who so wanted to take Sanjaya’s smile away and have him cry like he did tonight. Some of you even wanted his fans to get crushed. This is just a reminder of how cynical our society has become these days. We could use a lot more Sanjaya’s in the world — fearless, passionate, joyful. We knew exactly who Sanjaya was on this show. And he gave us everything he could possibly give in his performances. Some of you may have found it funny or a travesty, but he gives me hope.

I wouldn’t be blogging about American Idol for 3 years now if it was merely a singing competition. It is about rooting for the singer we are most greatly attached to, not finding the best “vocalist” — it’s always clear who that is on Day 1. Every one of the contestants who have appeared on this show has been cast to appeal to all sorts of tastes in American society, be it the little girls, middle-aged women, or male doctors who like to look at legs. I am not surprised that in this blog, people have found common ground with others via the Idols they admire.

This year, in Melinda Doolittle, those who have stayed in the sidelines too long in search of a second chance finally have someone to root for. I think she will win. But whoever does win in a few weeks will only be an afterthought in Idol mythology. American Idol Season 6 already belongs to Sanjaya.

Sanjaya Forever!

(Please give me a few moments as I wipe the tears away.)

Video clip:

Dailymotion blogged video

And because you want it, Rickey’s reaction shot: (I tried my best to get a good dramatization, but this is the best I can do since I’m a bit upset. LOL Also, we welcome Pee & Poo to our little cast. All efforts are welcome even if we were not successful tonight.):

120 Comments for Sanjaya Malakar — It’s Over.

1

I’m sorry Rickey.

Jaya will be missed.

Hugs to you both!

MissTara on April 18, 2007 at 10:04 pm
2

it had to happen sometime. phil is next

Kia00 on April 18, 2007 at 10:05 pm
3

I am sorry, RICKEY. Sanjaya kept the show fun and interesting this year and his crying broke my heart. It wont be the last we hear from him.

BIG HUG, my friend.

AceLuver on April 18, 2007 at 10:06 pm
4

that was so sad.
he hugged LaKisha for a very long time, but they seemed to be the only two that were crying.
i’m going to miss him. he was a great kid and very entertaining. good luck to him in the future.

What. on April 18, 2007 at 10:06 pm
5

RICKEY, my friend, I am with you tonight. A year ago I was in the same boat and you were there for me and my friends. Just remember, Sanjaya is Love!

richie on April 18, 2007 at 10:06 pm
6

I’m sorry Rickey. It was sad to see him go…I mean I think America got it right, but to see him crying…awww.

Janizzle on April 18, 2007 at 10:08 pm
7

Omg, this pic you posted sent me back off the edge! I am crying again!!

Us fans will keep him alive!!!! I know he will make a cd!

sugamamadaddy on April 18, 2007 at 10:08 pm
8

Bye bye ya, Sanjaya!!!! Long overdue. Now this is definitely something to talk about

yvette41 on April 18, 2007 at 10:09 pm
9

I love Sanjay’a spirit and sense of humor.
He is going to soar.

#7 is a special spot.

Virtual hug, Rickey.

DealMeAnAce on April 18, 2007 at 10:09 pm
10

A class act to the end, and a very nice sing out, I might add. Something tells me this is not the last we will hear of Sanjaya.

richie on April 18, 2007 at 10:09 pm
11

i felt bad for Sanjaya as it is. Atleast now he will move on. Even now at this young an age he has achieved a lot and has so many doors of opportunity open for him. I give a standing applause to Sanjaya to show courage and face the world everyweek even though he knew half of America hated him.

Now he will go ahead and sign contracts and commercials with peace and maybe some movies

Great job till now Sanjaya and hope to see you more of you.

Sorry Rickey.

bubblingice on April 18, 2007 at 10:10 pm
12

Tears of Joy!

snappydresser on April 18, 2007 at 10:11 pm
13

I was afraid of this. He will be missed!!!!

newtoai on April 18, 2007 at 10:11 pm
14

Aw, and when you think about it, isn’t Sanjaya’s Lucky number 7, and he got off 7th? How ironic…

Janizzle on April 18, 2007 at 10:13 pm
15

I love Jordin too, but I seriously don’t know if I’m going to watch the rest of the season. No one had pulling power like OUR BABY…maybe I’ll watch just to be able to get a glimpse of him in the audience.

HEY, RICKEY, AT LEAST WE GET TO SEE SANJAYA HIT THE TALK SHOW CIRCUIT IN THE NEXT FEW WEEKS!!! Not to mention all the countless endorsements and career to follow!!!!!

A thought: Where was his family???? Friends from yesterday?????

EggTart on April 18, 2007 at 10:14 pm
16

Sanjaya has taken more criticism than all of us put together. He has a strong character and never showed any signs of breaking down until now. Much luck in the future.

Lisa-Lisa on April 18, 2007 at 10:16 pm
17

RICKEY, it’s not the end it’s the beginning of something better. We love you!

SaveAHorseRideBlake on April 18, 2007 at 10:17 pm
18

Thanks Rickey for being a bright spot. We just all need to get over this hump and things will only get better now.

sukey on April 18, 2007 at 10:19 pm
19

Sorry, Rickey. I did love him too.
He’s so adorable and looks like a warm-hearted
person. I think he’s gonna have a good chance in
singing in the near future.
Bye, Sanjaya!!!

jiniwini on April 18, 2007 at 10:19 pm
20

Wow. I can honestly say I will not make a point of watching the show from now on. It was fun to see what he would do. Sanjaya has a great spirit and will be missed. I know there are better singers, but its just really boring.

Simon is the goat this week. How ironic.

Dalila1542 on April 18, 2007 at 10:20 pm
21

xoxo Rickey! xoxo Sanjaya

anne on April 18, 2007 at 10:22 pm
22

I actually thought Lakisha’s performance was worse than his… but it’s been a looong time coming. Kiki has to sing spectacularly well next week or it’ll be bye bye to her too.

nanda on April 18, 2007 at 10:22 pm
23

somewhere on the radio there were talks that this is going to be fixed and sanjaya WILL BE OUT today… nebody heard abt it?

bubblingice on April 18, 2007 at 10:23 pm
24

I honestly cried for Rickey when they announced Sanjaya was going home. I am sure many of us here were feeling the same sadness for you, Rickey.

And now… watch the endorsements line up.

He’s only just begun.

kookoo on April 18, 2007 at 10:24 pm
25

He went out with dignity, but let his youth show at the end. Remember: he’s still a kid compared with, say, Melinda.

I hope he goes home with his head high and follows a path that works for him.

But for the sake of J Records, Clive Davis and Simon Cowell, I’m glad that the voters have moved into a new, more serious gear.

randomduck on April 18, 2007 at 10:25 pm
26

It’s quite ironic he went out tonight when Dave from Vote 4 the Worst was a guest on David Letterman last night (Tuesday). I honestly never believed they or the Stern bimbos were keeping his votes up there. They like to take credit– until they fail. Can you picture someone dialing for hours just because Howard Stern tells them to? I don’t think so.

kookoo on April 18, 2007 at 10:26 pm
27

Sanjaya is being unleashed into the real world. he’s all OURS now!!!!!!!!

that thought just stopped the tears

EggTart on April 18, 2007 at 10:27 pm
28

Awww, I’m sorry RICKEY. ((((HUGS))))
Don’t forget, all us PEEPS love ya!

flygirl on April 18, 2007 at 10:27 pm
29

That’s weird how Sanjaya is all of a sudden eliminated without being in the bottom 3 (i don’t know if he’s been in the bottom 3 before; but at least he hasn’t for weeks). It’s also funny that 38 million votes came in and American Idol had the most top 7 votes ever. America was really pushing to have their favorites to stay over Sanjaya.

meisha210 on April 18, 2007 at 10:28 pm
30

I’m done with that show. Not only because Sanjaya left but because of how rudely he was treated. No one deserves cruel comments like that, especially a 17 year-old kid. I hope Sanjaya gets a record contract asap and makes millions.

sunflower21 on April 18, 2007 at 10:29 pm
31

Now that I think about it…While I will miss the excitement of wondering what he would do…the thought of any more brutality toward him would have been to much.
The juxtoposition of Simons(old) awful cynical performance/comments/eye rolls, and Sanjayas (young)open and positive vibe will linger.

Dalila1542 on April 18, 2007 at 10:31 pm
32

Well, as one door closes, anotheris supposed to open, just not as fast as we would like. Sanajay was a sweetie, just a kid with a sweet voise, big heart and even bigger grin. Lucky Number Seven. Sigh. Hugs Rickey. Love to you.

lotus on April 18, 2007 at 10:31 pm
33

I sawwy. :[

xkhboyninjax on April 18, 2007 at 10:32 pm
34

Wow, I am so choked up I can’t spell or punctuate!

lotus on April 18, 2007 at 10:33 pm
35

A lot of people will be so happy tonight! Can you imagine if with what happened in VA and Sanjaya survived again tonight, the whole nation will be so depressed! So at least this is something to cheer up lots of people out there. To be honest, I don’t like or hate him, he’s just like those normal kids out there: voice, look, personality, stage performance… So he’s extremely lucky to get this far

Johncarrie on April 18, 2007 at 10:34 pm
36

Take heart because the phenomenon of Sanjaya was not just created by the stupid WFTW and Howard Sterns … this kid has something. I think ultimately he could have a singing career, but I’m guessing for now he’s going to be snapped up in tv/movies … odds on a realife sitcom with the Malakar family?!!! What a nice, classy kid! Go Sanjaya!!!

szjodic on April 18, 2007 at 10:35 pm
37

awww, rickey. I’m sad right along with you. In a real way, Sanjaya *was* AI6. The show without Sanjaya is almost unthinkable! I mean, he was running out of kooky hair options, and he was gonna have to get mighty creative. See what you took from us, American Idol?? Damn you, American Idol!!

So, Rickey, is it R&K for you monday morning?

laff on April 18, 2007 at 10:38 pm
38

sweetangel1051 on April 18, 2007 at 10:39 pm
39

today i was more interested on what emma (martina’s daughter) has to say than anything else….

tutudenis on April 18, 2007 at 10:40 pm
40

I know.

This is more shocking then the time I watched Family Guy and heard that Meg got a Sex change after college.
Stewie: “Wow…. Meg went to college?”

xkhboyninjax on April 18, 2007 at 10:46 pm
41

Thank God!

jackson on April 18, 2007 at 10:49 pm
42

To be fair, I don’t think Sanjaya was treated rudely. I think he was given a “starring” role this season and he held it as long as he could. Simon saying his performance was terrible is not any more rude than when he made fun of Clay post-GREASE performance (and undeservingly so, IMO). They are there to be judged. In the “real” music world, Sanjaya would never have had this much exposure so let’s wish him well and hope that he gets a lot of commercials and air time… and let’s hope he gets to promote more than his hair. :>

kookoo on April 18, 2007 at 10:50 pm
43

He was terrible last night. He should have been voted off many weeks ago.

Now it’s Chris’ turn. Time to go.

zader on April 18, 2007 at 10:50 pm
44

Sanjaya you are a hero, and so are you rickey! and all other fans of sanjaya! We brought him to this level. I kinda feel bad cos I didn’t vote for him yesterday, although I didn’t think he was the worst, I couldn’t bear the judges and everyone critisizing him too much……we will love you sanjaya…keep smiling..

Rickey ….great job buddy. Waiting for the videos..cant wait to watch sanjaya’s home video…how did the audience respond? How was his performance after the result?

Yogikanna on April 18, 2007 at 10:54 pm
45

Just looking at sanjaya’s pic crying makes me sad…..I hope the haters are happy now…please don’t be mean to him when he gets out….we love you sanjaya

Yogikanna on April 18, 2007 at 10:58 pm
46

I’m sorry, Rickey. I knew those gutless wonders wouldn’t let him be part of their precious Special. Booooooooring!

Sanjaya is a good sport and he has a better sense of humor than anyone on that show. He’ll be fine. I look forward to seeing him on the Talk Show circuit.

EggTart, belated hug — you delicious dessert, you.

dateandtime on April 18, 2007 at 11:00 pm
47

hey, guys! take as long as you want with your grieving, but take some time off to vote for rickey at the blogger’s choice awards! =)

vonjobi on April 18, 2007 at 11:00 pm
48

let’s give em’ something to talk about, other than hair, hair hair!

I love sanjaya! he’s so cool…

willay on April 18, 2007 at 11:14 pm
49

vonjobi, thanks for the tip … all, here’s the link:
http://www.bloggerschoiceawards.com/blogs/show/88

vote for rickey!!!

szjodic on April 18, 2007 at 11:15 pm
50

about damn time!!!!!! now he’s got a career in the circus!!!!! there you go!!!!
now, we move on to the serious voting on this show……. go jordin!!!!

DrTrish197 on April 18, 2007 at 11:19 pm
51

Sorry, Rickey. That was sad. But he went out with class & humor of his own. Surely, good things will be coming for him.

JoAllison on April 18, 2007 at 11:33 pm
52

We will remain in the “Universe of Sanjaya”, at my house. He is our American Idol for this season. In the end this is just a TV show, it doesn’t define who a person is…nor what they become in their lives. We know Sanjaya will follow his dreams and be successful in his own right.
We support Sanjaya – -always. We find one sense of peace this night, in that America can now become obsessed with another AI contestant and spend all their waking hours …all their energy in hating the new victim. And sadly, that most likely will happen…
The world is yours, Sanjaya…ain’t no mountain high enough…ain’t no valley low…

SilverWillow on April 18, 2007 at 11:33 pm
53

Awee.
His eliminantion made me cry. It was so sad.

xkhboyninjax on April 18, 2007 at 11:39 pm
54

Sanjaya will be missed he was a sweet kid. I just saw him on a fox interview(well it was from right after the show) and Sanjaya said that he was never into country music and will see what happens next) He still had tears in his eyes. One thing for sure there will never be another Sanjaya he was the real deal and in the song he sang it said something like lets spread love instead of hate. That is so true and that message should apply to all especially to those who actually hated Sanjaya.

I think I feel just as sad as you do Rickey, but cheer up maybe you’ll meet him when he’s on Regis And Kelly. It’s about time Sanjaya gets to meet his #1 fan.

Donna on April 18, 2007 at 11:41 pm
55

I think today was sanjaya’s greatest performance…His voice just shone, did anyone else feel the same way?! It was sad to see him go…but I just thought he was amazing today, I guess yesterday he was a little nervous but if he had sung it like today….even simon had a surprised look

Yogikanna on April 18, 2007 at 11:58 pm
56

I’m going to miss Sanjaya and all the laughs he’s given me. From the wacky hairstyles to the hula dancing to the crying fangurl, his “going home” video was hilarious. He was a bad singer, but made great TV. I’m not sure how this boring season of AI is going to do without him. Best of luck to him and the Universe of Sanjaya.

red dress on April 19, 2007 at 12:16 am
57

Rickey, very emotional video, you respresnt all of us sanjaya fans…..i am almost in tears

Yogikanna on April 19, 2007 at 12:18 am
58

it is ridiculous to say that those who wanted Sanjaya to go wanted this to happen to “take away his smile and cause him to cry”. Is that what you wanted to happen to everyone else that has left the competition? I don’t think so. People cry when they leave the show because it’s a stressful and incredibly hard process. Just because we don’t share your obsession with him does not mean that we had malicious thoughts about him either. I think Sanjaya is a beautiful person with a light that will shine way after Idol is over. I know this is not the last we will hear about him for years to come, and predict with his fan base will become the new face of MANY products/shows.

That being said, I DO think every person that is left deserves to be there over him right now, and just because that is my opinion does not condone such a statement from you.

[ I wrote so many of you, not those of you. Please just stop the hating on the fans. Until the very end, you guys just can't help yourselves. You already got what you wanted. And there are many Phil-haters out there who disagree with you. No one does not NOT deserve. No one is entitled to be on the show. And if this is how you feel, then you are obviously not the so many I was referring to so don't get bothered by it. -- R. ]

oboeadam on April 19, 2007 at 12:28 am
59

YOGIKANNA, I have to agree with you, and hope that maybe RICKEY will make it available for download. I thought he sounded very good tonight.

richie on April 19, 2007 at 12:33 am
60

Rickey ((((HUGS))))

i’m sure things will open up for Sanjaya!!!

AZIdolFan on April 19, 2007 at 12:43 am
61

Sweet Rickey. I am sorry your favorite is gone from Idol. My heart aches more for you now than it did when ACE left during AI5 but, as we have seen with ACE, 7 is a good number. I can only imagine how giddy you will be if Sanjaya does the same meet-n-greets like ACE has been doing.

WHAT – I took note of the long hug between Lakisha and Sanjaya as well. I believe they were both in need of it. There were streaks down Lakisha’s face when they first came back, before they even gave the results. I believe they were both frozen in that moment. I don’t think that the others not crying meant there were bad vibes between any of them. Their faces were very solemn and when they showed the group after Lakisha joined them, Melinda was holding her like the mother of the group which I figure they’ve made her to be.

That said, I liked Sanjaya for his spirit, his smile, and the fun he had on stage but, truth… it was time.

Becki on April 19, 2007 at 12:43 am
62

Awww, Rickey. I’m sorry. I didn’t see (shiny happy) Pee/Poo too well, but I’m glad they’re keeping you company.
Hey — just think of all the Sanjaya-on-talk-shows blogging you’ll be doing. Cheer up, for like Sanjaya’s t-shirt says, life is beautiful.

VOTE FOR RICKEY! VOTE FOR RICKEY!
http://www.bloggerschoiceawards.com/blogs/show/88

dateandtime on April 19, 2007 at 1:01 am
63

I’m sad, too.

Pursuit on April 19, 2007 at 1:10 am
64

Probably one of the saddest days in Idol history, at least, for me. I mean no Sanjaya wasn’t the best singer in the competition, but I became attached to him as well. I don’t know. I was praying hard for him, but I guess sometimes things aren’t meant to be. I thought it would have been great for him to stay a few weeks longer. Like about a week or two. I just wanted him to make Top 6 for “Idol Gives Back” thats all. After that I was content with when he left since I know it would’ve been hard for him to win it and I felt others deserved the win initially. But…..I feel he will have a great career ahead of him in music. YOU JUST WATCH!. Rickey you have been a GREAT supporter of Sanjaya, I think thats great. I’m really saddened to see Sanjaya go. I’ll be honest, as a straight dude, it really breaks MY heart that he’s now gone. I just wish things were switched around and Kiki went home. Next week won’t be as exciting for me as it would’ve been with Sanjaya around. I hope he comes on Wednesday for their special at least. Man….I can’t believe I’m that torn. The last time I felt this for Idol was when Elliott left. Wow. J-Hud was first….Sanjaya is next. He’ll be alright.

shadow25 on April 19, 2007 at 1:10 am
65

Be strong Rickey!. You’ll be alright, my friend. I’m feeling the SAME way. haha

shadow25 on April 19, 2007 at 1:10 am
66

Thanks again Rickey – West Coast here, so just saw the singout and wow, his video was amazing. What a persona. This season has been GREAT already, don’t care what anyone says – what a nice group of talented kids – it’s just a great show. I like them all more each week. Maybe I’m just more attached because I’ve watched it from the start for the first time this year, but they all seem really attached to each other – it’s just nice. And they are damn talented (repeating myself, but I’m just sick of people going on and on about the lack of talent).
I’m looking forward to seeing what Sanjaya comes up with next!
Peace.

szjodic on April 19, 2007 at 1:20 am
67

Yogikanno, I thought that Sanjaya sang it really good tonight as well. I guess he wasn’t singing for competition so he was able to let his sweet voice shine through. Simon did have a surprised look maybe he was thinking hey this kid really did sing pretty good and I was always mean to him.

Donna on April 19, 2007 at 1:24 am
68

Wet eyes, 2nd time tonight. Amen to that beautiful post, Rickey; AI6 belongs to Sanjaya Malakar.

I don’t mean to be all ironic and bring up what Sanjaya sang against tonight, but…his hair! I think there’s something beautiful about the continuity and full cycle of it all:

Sanjaya’s hair looks exactly as it did when he first made it to Hollywood. He’s had crazy ups and downs during his entire run (hair, emotion, performance); he’s had his days when he probably felt on top of the world, and others when he’s felt like shit.

But now, at the end of it, he’s just being returned to who he always was: a natural, charming floppy-haired kid who will go far.

We’ll see you on the other side, bb.

And I second D&T’s comment! I’m SO looking forward to all the talk-show clips you’ll be putting up on here! (Please please pretty pleeease??)

Hugs all around! :”’(

EggTart on April 19, 2007 at 1:33 am
69

My empathy to you Rickey!

But please don’t feel that Sanjaya cried b/c ppl were so mean to him or all of the negativity. He cried b/c an intense journey has just ended and I’m sure it was a very special experiene for him.

He’ll be all over the media starting tomorrow. So you can enjoy him via a different avenue.

His crying was really touching and beautiful.

GO SANJAYA!

heavyblow on April 19, 2007 at 1:46 am
70

I have one message for darling Sanjaya….don’t go to any of those talk shows , you know those poeple right Jay leno, letterman etc…they don’t give a damn about you, they will just make fun of you to get attention…stay away from them until you sell a lot of albums…it’s good for you that way.

Yogikanna on April 19, 2007 at 1:47 am
71

I can’t wait to hear what kind of music he makes. I’ll definitely be looking out for him. He put up with a lot of BS from everyone, and no one deserves that kind of treatment. He definitely won me over as the weeks went by.

I do love all the remaining contestants though. No matter what people say, this has been a great season of AI for the amazing talent and people they found this year. Sanjaya; you rock! Go on with your bad self.

kceycrk on April 19, 2007 at 2:08 am
72

Sanjaya for sure went out with class and dignity. I am pretty sure he’ll probably make an album at some point. I only wish all good things for Sanjaya.With his charm, talent, and personality, I know he will make it big.Just like Sanjaya’s shirt says, Life Is Beautiful.

We love ya Rickey!

We love ya Sanjaya!

Donna on April 19, 2007 at 2:26 am
73

Awww. Poor Sanjaya, it totally broke my heart to see him crying like that!! He’s a sweet and adorable guy and made this season so much better and entertaining for me. I’ll miss him but I’m glad he had such fun and a great experience while it lasted – and I’m sure doors will just open up for him. We’ll miss you, Sanjaya!

Sorry, Rickey, we know he’s your favorite! But for what it’s worth, you and your blog totally rock.

Cinny_72 on April 19, 2007 at 2:51 am
74

At the beginning of this season, I couldn’t stand Sanjaya. I did like his audition, but after that I didn’t understand why he was still in the competition.

Man, how my opinion has changed over the past few weeks. I thought it was funny that he was staying in the competition. Then, I really began to enjoy Sanjaya – the hair, the performances, the entertainment. I even voted for him many times the past couple of shows – over one hundred times just last night. I think the show will be boring without him, which is why I probably won’t be watching.

I am really disappointed that he is gone. I think he has handled himself very well throughout this whole thing. He has probably learned a lot from this experience, and being only 17 years old, he will probably continue to learn from this experience throughout his life. I wish him the best with whatever he chooses to do next in life!

Kayla on April 19, 2007 at 3:03 am
75

As I’ve been saying before, Sanjaya seems like a really sweet kid. And it did tug at the heartstrings watching him tear up.
But sorry.. He had to go. He wasn’t right for the competition and it was far past his time to get cut.
I’m sure he’s going to have a ton of offers from everywhere though so you won’t see the last of him.

Pallaton on April 19, 2007 at 3:05 am
76

Just like a few people here, many others today will have tears in their eyes too. Not because they’re sad, but because they’re so happy now that the real competition can begin. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t hate him at all. He’s just an average kid: his voice is just like a decent karaoke type voice, childlike singing voice and he’s not even entertaining like William Hung. He’s just a well mannered kid. That’s all! Scott Savol & Chicken Little have better voice. He’s so extremely lucky to be this far!

Johncarrie on April 19, 2007 at 3:25 am
77

Shared Tears with you Rickey.

My living room will emptier every week.

Sanjaya is, hands down, the most inspirational person Idol has ever brought to the stage. That special heart-warming smile may not have impressed enough – but it certainly gave most of us something good to talk about.

Lady Kate on April 19, 2007 at 3:39 am
78

Hi Rickey…
I’m so sorry bout Sanjaya.
I like him too and I’m gonna miss that wacky-hair kid. He is not the best performer on AI (though he has a very good voice), but he steal people’s attention by showing his smile, hairstyles, stage performances, personality and… his family! People sometimes forget his singing talent.

All loves and hatred go to him actually come from this ‘attracted’ feeling.
People who love Sanjaya can’t wait to see him every week: what kind of song/music will he perform? what kind of hairdo?
And people who dislike him also can’t wait to see their I-hate-this-kid one, and next, they got something from Sanjaya to ridicule.

I just wish he still there at AI shows every week, even he’s not singing, just sits among the audience EVERY WEEK with different hairstyles and wave to camera when they shoot him… hahaha… wadaya think?
no mean to make the rest of AI contestants jealous.

lei on April 19, 2007 at 4:58 am
79

Rickey, don’t get your hopes down. It’s not “over.” Sanjaya is still alive. He may not be on the show anymore, but he sure isn’t going anywhere. He’ll be on all the talk shows, he’ll go somewhere. I personally didn’t think he was all that well-suited for the competition, but he is suited for the entertainment industry. Sanjaya is not gone, he’s just getting started.

julianvelasquez on April 19, 2007 at 5:02 am
80

Sanjaya will be rich. Believe it. Plus, everyone goes sometime except for one person who wins. I agree that Sanjaya was a great kid. As for last night, I think Blake was stunned to be in the bottom 3 — especially after he got raves and is considered a favorite.

dklml on April 19, 2007 at 7:06 am
81

Rickey, your reaction video brings me back to the emotions I was feeling when Chris Sligh went home. I truly feel for you. Your post is beautiful and so true, Sanjaya managed to shine in the face of adversity. As Sligh reminded us on his blog, we need to all say a prayer for Sanjaya ans he ventures into the negavite world of the media… unfortunately, they’ll be swarming him like vultures. Sligh survived it, but he’s over ten years older than Sanjaya and could handle it- I’m hoping Sanjaya is OK. Poor kid. Thanks for being great, Rickey! and hang in there.

The History Cutie

*Love to VA Tech*

HstryQT on April 19, 2007 at 7:21 am
82

I feel that he should have been gone prior to now, but I’m glad he made the impact he made – it should lead to wonderful things for him and a totally different life than he had before.

I know people have their opinions, and for some reason people seem to think that they need to gloat, but really – is this the place to do it? Obviously, Rickey loved Sanjaya and is brokenhearted – he created this site for us to enjoy each week. I don’t feel it is appropriate for people to come into “his house” and gloat about the elimination of his favorite. He deserves more respect than that.

There are other places to go and gloat – if that’s something you feel you just need to do. I think everyone needs to remember that he’s a kid – someone’s son. If you have kids, he could be your kid, etc.

MindyLCK on April 19, 2007 at 7:46 am
83

Morning Rickey,
Thanks for the posts. In particular I appreciate your reaction video. You’ve created something very special with this blog. We all get to meet up and hash out our similarities and differences but brought together by the shows that entertain us. You share more than your generous videos and screencaps. You offer yourself to us in a very real way. Thanks, man.

Spriggzoid on April 19, 2007 at 9:04 am
84

Although I’m quoting from Rickey’s comments, my comments are not pointed directly at Rickey personally but the entire Sanjaya Universe (lame). “…thrust into the spotlight on the most popular show on Earth…”, you’re joking right? I’d say jumped headlong into the spotlight is more like it. “…he held himself with dignity in the face of relentless adversity.” It must be tough to exist under this type of ‘adversity’. Kind of like living in Iraq or Darfur right about now, huh. Get a friggin’ grip! Your favorite boy was voted off, sack up and be a man about it and pick another favorite. I’m sorry to be the one to tell you all this, but Sanjaya may be successful at something in the entertainment industry, however it won’t be as a recording artist. Oh I suppose he could be a one hit wonder, but that’s the best he can hope for regarding singing. Perhaps I’m jaded because I don’t understand the attraction to such lack of talent, and I didn’t sit around moping and crying upon Sanjaya’s departure…or perhaps I’m a grown-up and not a 13 year old girl. Go Doolittle! Talent should always be the winner.

williboy71 on April 19, 2007 at 9:07 am
85

I just found you, Rickey. I’m with you. It’s weird how a part of me feels torn away and I feel so sad. Sanjaya was the embodiment of hope and potential, good natured, good humoured and good looking. Every bit the idol. I adored him and wish him much love and success.

Rosalind on April 19, 2007 at 9:11 am
86

RICKEY, I’m sorry, I know exactly how you feel

#7 is a special spot, you’ll realize it later.

It was only the beggining for Ace, and for Sanjaya won’t be different.

Sabrina on April 19, 2007 at 9:11 am
87

That was seriously beautiful. Once again you’ve put to words everything I want to say. I actually cried when he got voted out. It was awful. But this is not the end of him & I can’t wait till his CD comes out. =]

zomgaubrie on April 19, 2007 at 9:12 am
88

I cried along with Sanjaya all night. Rickey, I am not going to watch AI anymore, AI without Sanjaya, is not worth it. Hugs to you and good luck with whatever you are doing. I stumbled upon your blog while googling for Sanjaya and I must say that I am glad to have met you, someone who is truly spirited and carries so much positive energy, just like Sanjaya.

SANJAYA is my American Idol this season and yes you are absolutely right, Season 6 belonged to Sanjaya already, it does not matter who is crowned.

*Hearts and hugs * to Sanjaya. WISH HIM SUCCESS.

snazzy on April 19, 2007 at 9:30 am
89

RICKEY, I hope you are well this morning, and recovering from last night’s events.

I find it hard to understand why a 17-year-old boy could show show much grace and class last night under the glaring eye of national television than some of the so-called adult posters on this board. I don’t know why I am surprised, as it has tended to be the case this season.

richie on April 19, 2007 at 9:47 am
90

I thought that was so cute when Sanjaya was singing he sang Lets Talk About Love Other than Hate, and Lets Give Them something To Talk About Other Than Hair Hair Hair. He is such an adorable sweet kid and I know many good things will come his wat. Hey Mr Tony Bennet said He thought Sabjaya was Great and Dianna Ross said that Sanjaya is love.

Donna on April 19, 2007 at 10:00 am
91

I will begin with a comment to one of the existing comments.

Melinda was crying too. Melinda and Lakisha both seemed to really like Sanjaya. If you have paid attention to their interactions throughout, the 3 of them seemed close. Can’t wait to hear exit interviews and such to see how he’s holding up.

Rickey! Thank you for posting this beautiful message. I didn’t know anything about his family life. We forget, he’s only 17. For someone that young, he’s got a bright future ahead of him, and I will miss wondering “what they heck will Sanjaya do this week?” His time was up, though. I felt – if he stayed a week or two longer, the show would suffer, as talented (he/she could win) people were sent home, instead. Lakisha, although, recently lackluster, has the ability to win. I feel this was the perfect time for Sanjaya to head on home. When the top 12 began, I said, “he will make #7.” I thought I would be wrong after latin night. GREAT JOB, SANJAYA!

About his exit… I just wish it wasn’t so “FINALLY! YES! HE’S GONE!” I feel for him. I hope to hear things from him after the tour. He needs a little vocal training, maybe, that’s about it. I will always remember his cute audition, in which he indirectly showed up his sister.

DJJayito on April 19, 2007 at 10:02 am
92

Oh. My boyfriend and I were upset at how the audience cheered. That wasn’t right.

DJJayito on April 19, 2007 at 10:04 am
93

Yes Rickey, what you wrote about Sanjaya was simply beautiful Sanjaya was very special, sweet, talented and loved by many people. The people that really hated Sanjaya are very imature and ignorant in my opinion.

Last night when Sanjaya sang his farewell song he sang with so much feeling alomg with his cute wording. He really did sound great. I know he’ll make an album with his sweet smooth voice and it will surely sound beautiful.

Donna on April 19, 2007 at 10:27 am
94

Thank you for your beautiful words Rickey. I appreciate your support of Sanjaya more than you’ll ever know.

snuffles on April 19, 2007 at 10:39 am
95

Rickey, my heart goes out to you. Sanjaya was such a sweet kid and really handled the whole thing with such dignity and spirit.

I’m sending you some cyber kleenex.

Kimber on April 19, 2007 at 10:48 am
96

Rickey, that was very touching. Sanjaya, keep smiling. There are great things in store for you.

pj1465 on April 19, 2007 at 11:14 am
97

I mean, no offense meant to the Viginia tech victims (my heart goes out to them and their families), this is why people go crazy because of the discrimination they suffer. I really hate what they did to Sanjaya. Imagine, going to the extent of having to stage a hunger strike just to see him eliminated.
he may not be the most talented of singers, but he sure had the charm and a sunny personality. I’m sure he’ll go a long long way.
and i agree with you, rickey, American idol 6 belongs to sanjaya, irregardless of who America chooses to be their Idol!
Good luck Sanjaya!

jayaSan on April 19, 2007 at 11:28 am
98

Man you’re right ricky. Its kinda funny after Simon gave the WORST comment he’s ever given sanjaya, he gets the boot. I think he said something like “You shouldn’t be in this competition”…and out he goes. Simon is very pissed at this and i know why too. He makes a living on deciding what OTHER people will like and what people don’t. And the fact that people are voting for sanjaya and LIKE him simply because he is so sweet, nice, and funny irks him i think. Not so much the fact that there are better singers, but the fact that his “authority” over what people do and don’t like has been hindered. Meh, in my opinion.

Your post was dead on though. Sanjaya’s run on AI…as entertaining as he was, was more than just that. The adversity and cruel hostility tells me something about the media and public at large.

Can’t wait for the interviews! Sanjaya is a class act!

yolanda7g on April 19, 2007 at 11:58 am
99

Hi Ricky my first time to post here. I stop watching AI since after the second season (Reuben and Clay)( I still think that AI Producers have the final say who goes and who stay)I got interested watching American Idol again only because of Sanjaya. He made the show more interesting and He dared to be different.I was sad too when he got voted off (I don’t believe for one minute his fans turned against him just because of one night? ) His elimination from the show is only part of his journey. The show just prepared him how to face adversity with dignity and honor.At the tender age of 17 He’ll be ready for the next journey. We will hear more from him. I wish him the very best luck.Now AI is not so interesting show to watch anymore for me anyway.By the way Ricky, Great website!

Dabest3 on April 19, 2007 at 12:00 pm
100

“We could use a lot more Sanjaya’s in the world — fearless, passionate, joyful. We knew exactly who Sanjaya was on this show. And he gave us everything he could possibly give in his performances.”

Amen Ricky! Thanks so much for your blog! I was so sad to hear Sanjaya was booed at a baseball game. I admire him for doing all he did with the instrument he has, sparkling so, consistently speaking and demonstrating love, and the gentleness in his mischeviousness (again demonstrating love).

I thought Sanjaya’s reasons for choosing “Let’s give em something to talk about” were brilliant, as was his improvisation with the lyrics in his farewell song. I never voted for him (I voted for whom I thought were the better vocal performers: Melinda, Jordin, and once Blake), but applaud and cheer him nonetheless.
I hope he goes on to a huge Tiger Beat and Disney movie career, and I’m sure his CDs will sell! (I bought one of his AI studio performances). I hope he reads your blog! Bravo, Sanjaya! Namasté!

LoveVioletFlame on April 19, 2007 at 12:39 pm
101

Rickye!!! where are you. we need you to say something here. dont be so upset to not talk abt sanjaya nemore… we all want to know what is going on now with sanjaya.

where is he? whom is he talking to? how is he doing?
plzzzzzzzzzzzz plzzzzzzzzzzzzz give us updates. dont let sanjaya fade away.. plzzzzzzzzzzz

bubblingice on April 19, 2007 at 12:58 pm
102

To borrow the lyrics from a song featured in The Sound of Music . . .

How do you solve a problem like Sanjaya?
How do you catch a clown and pin it down?
How do you find a word that means Sanjaya?
A flibberti gibbet!
A willo’ the wisp!
A clown!
Many a thing you know you’d like to tell him,
Many a thing he ought to understand.
But how do you make him stay,
And listen to all you say?
How do you keep a wave upon the sand?
Oh, how do you solve a problem like Sanjaya?
How do you hold a moonbeam in your hand?

Ain’t no sunshine when he’s gone. We will miss you, Sanjaya!

Mrs. Robinson on April 19, 2007 at 1:15 pm
103

(((RICKEY)))

hey, number 7 is perfectly respectable. nestled right in there between our favorite numbers 8 and 6 (buck’n chick’n and pan, respectively).

see, now that they’ve lost sanjaya they’re counting on this self-indulgent charitypalooza to rake in the ratings. ugh.

amber on April 19, 2007 at 2:13 pm
104

HI,

In this morning af brutal media, it is nice to see someone who recognizes Sanjaya for what he is. I would not say he was my favorite, but he was the one I most wanted to see each week in this most boring of seasons.

Who knows how his album, and there will be an album, will turn out. He had curage and strength and humor that was sorely lacking in prior contestants. I think he was an excellent idol material in just standing up to the garbage thrown at him just on the idol show. Simon should be forced to look at his joyous face and then read the ratings. I find this year very boring and it is ingteresting that the performance ratings keep dropping as they are starting to protool some of the contestants to make them sound better (Blake, I am looking at you).

The interesting thing about the ratings this year is that the results show is out drawing the performance shows indicating that the stars are a draw and the contestants fade more into the background. (started at last years finale) I think that Idol is forgetting that the water cooler moments are performed by the contestants not the sometimes lipsyncing guest stars. Shark, I think you have been jumped.

linda6084 on April 19, 2007 at 2:27 pm
105

wherever fate takes you from now on… go sanjaya ji! many are there to support you already!

rozny on April 19, 2007 at 3:33 pm
106

sanjaya will be missed greatly i gotta say i was one of the ppl who didn’t like sanjaya at first but after watching him for a while he kind of grows on you. this season was so borring with out sanjaya its pretty funny ppl are saying it was him that was ruining the season , when in accuality it was him who saved this season. no one would care as much for idol this year if he wasn’t in it. if you saw david letterman and dave from vftw said it best , if your good it doesn’t really matter what spot you finish in idol your going to make it after idol no matter what and sell copies of your cd. it would have just been awsome to see sanjaya win a recordinig contract. but , it was pretty cool to see sanjaya come from bein this unknown shy lil kid to bein one of the most talked about names in this country. like him or not sanjaya became bigger then even american idol could handle.

abercrombieco2 on April 19, 2007 at 4:54 pm
107

Gosh, I feel really incomplete without having Sanjaya on the show.
He was boss.
He was an amazing singer he just needs a couple more years of dynamics.
there are worst people on the show.
im looking forward to hear some of sanjayas songs.
he is so popular he must be making an album soon.
In the words of chris daughtry “its not over”.

san_mal on April 19, 2007 at 5:41 pm
108

Bye, bye Sanjaya, hello boredom…
I only watched the Idol this year because of that kid…I think I lost interest. I really don’t care who will become the Idol.

Not that I ever thought Sanjaya would get as far as he did, but it was fun watching him and his stubborn struggle.
His last performance was not good. But I disagree with what so many say, that he has no talent. Plus, he carried himself really well, all this time.
Hugs to Rickey – don’t worry, Sanjaya will be back on tour. My only worry is, will the haters try to disrupt his parts of the performance. I’m really worried that there will be booing or something.

Stop the hatered people!!! He is a human being, a beautiful young man, with whole life in front of him. He is genuinely entertaining, in a good way. No need to stomp him. He doesn’t desereve to be treated with cruelty and disrespect.
Sanjaya, know that you are loved – let it give you strength to shake off the stupid abuse. Go on with your life, keep your head high, and don’t forget to smile!

tikkin on April 19, 2007 at 6:16 pm
109

I cried last night too, a lot! Not because I was sad but because I was so happy; tears of joy and as you all noticed, right after Ryan announced that he was going home, the whole audience also cheered in happiness because finally, the real competition can begin! Hahahh… Actually, just kidding! Seriously, I’m not Sanjaya hater because from the beginning, I could tell who’s good, who’s not. From the audition, I think his sister has better voice (and she’s hot!) but he’s not too bad. And when he was in Hollywood, some people hate him because his showmanship was boring, he was just so stiff and I think that it’s the main reason most people hate him since then. While most people started to hate him, as for me, I still didn’t hate him because I think he was just an unexperienced little kid but at least his voice is not so bad; so I still kept my opinion neutral, totally based on the facts. But then, just like most of other contestant, he improved slowly, but the further he was in, the big difference we could see between him and the rest of the group. Then, all of a sudden, I saw the little girl on TV cried when he performed and it was not even his best performance! That drove me nuts! But it turned out that she cried for everybody during the whole show, even until the end of the show when Ryan asked her to go on stage. So then, I knew that she was just a big fan of the show, in another word, everyone there was her idols! Hahahh! Anyway, some people talked like he was a biggest hero or something. That’s so bullcrap! First of all, most of those didn’t know him personally. Secondly, and most importantly, no one would even mentioned that the reason they like him is because he has better voice than the top 12 because they knew that his voice is good BUT NOT THAT GOOD AS THE REST OF THE GROUP. So, why do they like him? Because he’s entertaining? Come one, give me a break, his moves are still very awkward and stiff. Let assume that he was not from American Idol, when he performed like that at his concert, do you think girls will act crazy, jump out of their chairs and dance with him? I don’t think so. So they like him because he dare to be different just because of the Mohawk hair? So what, no big deal. Who knows, maybe that’s not even his idea, maybe it’s one of Hollywood hair stylists’ idea because his hair is long so they just want him to look a little different. Look at Haley, she has legs and she wear short, short short. THAT is dare to be different! As for his personality, he’s just a well mannered kid, nothing really stands out. Like Melinda, she’s so mellow (watch her audition from the beggining) or William Hung (”I have no regret because I already tried my best”) THAT’s what we call personality that stands out! Sanjaya is just like the rest of the group in the show, he didn’t act or say something special that makes us to remember (remember last year, when Paris Banette was still with the group, she was the one that cried like crazy whenever someone got booted off? THAT’s the one that stay in our memory!) Come one people! Stop acting like he’s your biggest idol or hero because then, everyone will be everybody’s heroes or idols and that is bull! Hahahahh…. Just wake up and smell the coffee! He’s a good kid and I admire him that he has a better voice than me (or alot of kids out there) when I was at his age (but is he better than Jordin? Paris Benette, Lisa Tucker, or even Kevin Covais from previous season?) and I wish him luck in the future. But believe me, he’s not my idol or hero in my heart because I have way higher standards than that

Johncarrie on April 19, 2007 at 9:12 pm
110

Quote: “To borrow the lyrics from a song featured in The Sound of Music . . .

How do you solve a problem like Sanjaya?
How do you catch a clown and pin it down?
How do you find a word that means Sanjaya?
A flibberti gibbet!
A willo’ the wisp!
A clown!
Many a thing you know you’d like to tell him,
Many a thing he ought to understand.
But how do you make him stay,
And listen to all you say?
How do you keep a wave upon the sand?
Oh, how do you solve a problem like Sanjaya?
How do you hold a moonbeam in your hand?

Ain’t no sunshine when he’s gone. We will miss you, Sanjaya!”

Comment: How do you catch A CLOWN and pin it down? I call clown abuse!!!! It’s “how do you catch a CLOUD and pin it down.” lolololololol. Don’t even ask me how I know this, but it’s true. Mrs. Robinson you are priceless.

Btw thank you Rickey for this site. I have never watched AI to this day but checked in with you the last 4 weeks just to check on Sanjaya. Something about this kid just captured my attention. I think Melinda is awesome and I always hoped she’d win, but I thought Sanjaya would stick around a little longer. I know great things are in store for him. Keep the faith!

hesterprune on April 19, 2007 at 9:19 pm
111

I’ve never been to the AI tour, but I can’t imagine anyone booing him on tour… everybody should just join the Sanjaya party for that night whether they like him or not then move on…

MindyLCK on April 19, 2007 at 9:30 pm
112

Sanjaya is gone and i am really sad. please keep blogging about him, ok? I loved your blog because we both like sanjaya.

When he was eliminated, everyone was clapping like crazy. and then, when he sang, everyone gave him “standing ovation”. i felt like he was insulted that time. everyone was happy, Simon COW was smiling…gaaah.

Hey please keep on writing about sanjaya. =D

camisado on April 19, 2007 at 11:39 pm
113

omg i cried soo much yesterday and watching it over makes me sad .. and seeing him cry i feel for you sanjaya ily. its not gonna be the same wihtout you.. no fun man uggh lol. and this morning everyone was like aww im soo sorry sanjaya left .. and people were rubbing in my face and i started to cry =(.. but at the end of the day i felt better cuz i know that ur gonna be a big star one day and i wanna be the first to buy your cd.. good luck ily

TEAMSANJAYA on April 19, 2007 at 11:44 pm
114

I kind of felt bad for him. He didn’t deserve all the negative things that were said about him. But, it happened, and, that is that.

But, though it may sound rude, I really wish he had left earlier. He wouldn’t have faced so much hardship if he had. And besides, I really wanted my idol to shine more. *I miss Gina more each day!*

But, your right in saying that Season 6 is owned my Sanjaya. All people will remember this season for was that it hosted the most popular contestant to date: Sanjaya. At least he won that title.

Bwatt27 on April 20, 2007 at 12:45 am
115

By SAM DOLNICK
NEW DELHI (AP) – Good riddance, Sanjaya. Indians seemed relieved to see oddball star Sanjaya Malakar, whose father hails from India, exit the “American Idol” stage after a long and unlikely run.
While Malakar’s goofy hairstyles and lackluster singing captivated millions of Americans, his quirky appeal never resonated among Indians. Though the end of his run Wednesday was front-page news, his exit was not mourned.
“Sanjaya is voted off American Idol — he’s the only one weeping,” read a front-page headline in The Indian Express, above a photo of his famous “ponyhawk” hairdo.
“Finally, Sanjaya sings his way out of ‘Idol,’ read a Times of India headline.
Indians never connected with Malakar, said Poonam Saxena, television critic for The Hindustan Times.
“He’ll be forgotten I’m sure, unless he does something else big. Why would anyone remember him?” she said, dismissing the 17 year-old as “a spunky kid.”
Perhaps Malakar’s failure to break out in India can be attributed in part to the broadcast schedule. News Corp. (NWS)’s Fox network show is seen a day late here, and on Star World TV, an English-language channel that attracts relatively few viewers in this country of 1.1 billion.
“We have all our own music competitions, like ‘Indian Idol’ and many other shows,” Saxena said. “On those, the kids sing the songs that the whole country knows by heart. The songs on Star World, no one has ever heard of 90 percent of them, so there’s no connection at all.”

Johncarrie on April 20, 2007 at 12:55 pm
116

Hesterprune, I’ve been known to botch the words to songs, for better or worse. I’ve been singing “clown” since I first saw that movie at the age of 2. Live and learn.

Mrs. Robinson on April 20, 2007 at 1:25 pm
117

hi..i’m from india..i hav been watchin american idol from the beginnin n sanjaya was my favourite contestent not becoz hez half indian but he is a really nice kid..his voice was not that bad n he definitely din’t deserve to b criticised so much..i accidently found this site n i’m so glad i did..i really like to thank rickey for puttin up such a good meaningful site..n m so glad der r many others hu share my grief in sanjaya’s eviction from AI…lots of luv!!!m glad sanjaya’s is doin great post AI..

fa_activate on April 21, 2007 at 1:44 am
118

Yes, he’s the most talked about this year. Yes he has some fans that vote like crazy. But he still sucked.

pud333 on April 21, 2007 at 8:35 pm
119

I felt bad when Ryan announced Sanjaya would be going home. I looked forward to seeing Sanjaya each week and I will miss him. Here is a link to a video I made about Sanjaya:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swCndDgiokE

Let’s hear it for the boy! He’s going to do well..just you wait and see!

Maureen

Maureen on April 22, 2007 at 3:38 am
120

It kinda hurts me that he had to go home.
i developed a kinda crush on him (i’m a few yrs younger than he is)
and idk i’ve never liked someone liek him before.
he’s just so charming and so cute!
it hurt rlly bad when he had to go home,
cuz i was really attached to him and
i was one of those fans who would vote for him every night.
And on elimination night i was PRAYiNG that he wasnt going home,
but i guess it was time for him to go.
I live on the west coast, so i was so desperate to find out if he was leaving.
i shouldnt have checked
because when i checked on here and i saw he was going home
my heart hurt so much i started crying so much.
when i actually watched it on tv, i held back the tears in my eyes….
and went to sleep.
but they next day at school
i just cried so much cuz i missed him
but for me, i’m so lucky because i live in his homestate.
i may meet him one day.
i know this was kinda corny
but i wanted to get my feelings out.

i love you sanjaya
and have a great career!!!

MELANiE M on May 8, 2007 at 10:20 am