American Idol

Who’s going home? Who’s your favorite? – American Idol 11 Top 5 – Poll

The American Idol 11 Top 5 took on music from the 60′s and Brit Pop.

I think Phillip Phillips is in danger so I’m going to vote for him non-stop tonight. Meanwhile, who do you think is going home? Who was your favorite?

Take the poll and watch the recap video:

Who’s Going Home?

(Facebook Required)

Who’s Going Home?

[polldaddy poll="6193847"]

Who’s Your Favorite?

[polldaddy poll="6193849"]

American Idol 11 Top 5  Poll

Follow me on Facebook!Follow me on Google+

Follow Me on Pinterest

American Idol American Idol 11Top 5Video

Got Something to Add?

74 comments
Mhay
Mhay

My cousin's name is KENSY CASTILLIO and we both agreed that is should be Hollie Cavanagh.

blink_boi28061980
blink_boi28061980

Hollie is getting better and better every week but still her voice is not quality... Little improvement of Hollie make more attention that's why her rating improving too..  

MusicFan
MusicFan

See.. I told you! Bye Skylar! :) Maybe AI is not for you. God has plan for you baby, don't worry! 

realphill
realphill

but holie owned the show last night! 2/2 knock outs!

realphill
realphill

its time for phillip to go home. i even liked joshua last night! 

XL
XL

Phillip revealed his girlfriend last night. That was his nail in the coffin. Everyone knows when your popularity is based on the fraun, you don't crush their dreams like that, lol.

jbeeeb
jbeeeb

Phillip should be gone. Hollie may be gone. My order of performance on the night...

1. Hollie (She has come so far and she killed both songs. Bleeding Love was a risk and she made it work).

2. Skylar (Girl can sing anything and has.  Her renditions of both songs were outstanding and she shows real versatility)

3.  Joshua (I thought he oversand "Ain't to Proud to Beg" a bit, but he was fantastic on "To Love Somebody".  He knows who is as an artist, and I love what he does.)

4. Jessica ("Proud Mary" was too predictable.  It was well performed but it came off as too much of a copy of Tina.  On the other hand what she did with "You are So Beautiful" was special. )

5.  Phillip (Clearly on another level for the night and that is not a good thing.  His performances don't capture you anymore.  Probably time to go.)

takakupo
takakupo

I would like to point out that once again, Hollie has the highest score of the night on whatnottosing and boy did she deserve it. I really think it was one hell of a song. 

 

http://whatnottosing.com/

Alansky
Alansky

I thought Jessica did a wonderful rendition of the song "You are so beautiful to me." "Proud Mary" wasn't hot for me. I wonder why she chose that song. And "ugh,ugh" for P2. I've had enough of him. I think he should go home tomorrow. But I am afraid that would not happen. Again, "ugh", and to think I "luv" him.

mwk89
mwk89

Skylar - 13.6, Hollie - 12.0, Joshua - 11.7, Jessica - 8.4, Phillip - 6.2  (not looking good for Rickey's Phillip)

mwk89
mwk89

Skylar is now in the green on DI

MusicFan
MusicFan

omg skylar, pls go home. Your version of you don't have to say you love me was a ___ :(

MusicFan
MusicFan

Skylar or Hollie should go home. Joshua, Jessica & Philip - TOP 3 im not a hater, you can really tell who is amazing and good.

 

Skylar- nasally

Hollie- always thinking when performing

 

 

Ross88
Ross88

Dial Idol only includes telephone votes right? i mean it doesn't include online voting? correct me if i'm wrong.

indigo1
indigo1

PhilipPhilips SUCKS!!!!!!!!!! But the sad thing is that there are people like Rickey who obviously doesn't know talent as he clearly wants him in his bed and I know several girls/f*gs who do the same. Pity! 

 

jayrold
jayrold

jessica should win american idol she deserved it.

jayrold
jayrold

hollie is the weakest of the night  she didn't hit  the notes right,i think jessica win this week ,hollie should go home.

jayrold
jayrold

jessica owned the stage.

jayrold
jayrold

jessica stand out she is amazing sososo talented

DawnStathus
DawnStathus

Here's how I rate the rounds

Round 1:

1. Hollie Cavanagh, River Deep, Mountain High

2. Phillip Phillips, The Letter

3. Skylar Laine, Fortunate Son

4. Joshua Ledet, Ain't Too Proud to Beg

5. Jessica Sanchez, Proud Mary

And Round Two:

1. Joshua Ledet, To Love Somebody

2. Jessica Sanchez, You Are So Beautiful

3. Hollie Cavanagh, Bleeding Love

4. Skylar Laine, You Don't Have to Say You Love Me

5. Phillip Phillips, Time of the Season

 

Given that:  It will probably be Skylar or P2 going home, unless the young girls really vote for P2, but I'm guessing that Holly may have pulled some of P2's votes tonight.  The younger girls I know have been rooting for her as the underdog and she's finally come into her own.

 

 

 

mwk89
mwk89

Phillip is going home

bwatt27
bwatt27

For my favorite, can I still vote Elise? 

elfstar89
elfstar89

That gif is too funny.  Phi is my least fave, but Josh needs to calm down and milk the less serious moments.

mwk89
mwk89

B2 now Jessica - 10, Phillip - 7.9

Noelle
Noelle

This season is so blah. Hollie was so vanilla and her notes are so one dimensional. And Joshua just comes off like an asshole tbh. Closet case or not.

mwk89
mwk89

 @myrsterious when there's such a huge gap, it usually is. Just look at last week, it had Elise. And it even had Colton when he left

hrstump
hrstump moderator

 @Ross88 Dial Idol only measures busy signals on phone lines and makes educated guesses.

NathanDG
NathanDG

 @indigo1 I for one wouldn't mind sleeping with P2 (if he promises not to distort his face while we're making out. LOL!) but that doesn't mean I'd vote for him so your point stands nullified. What an ignorant comment! You're such a douche!

takakupo
takakupo

 @indigo1 Watch your mouth asshole. Stereotyping is whatever but don't go around using derogatory words about gay people (or any group of people for that matter). 

takakupo
takakupo

 @jayrold Gurl, you scared! You so scared she gonna win American Idol before Jessica that you pooped and peed yo' pants!!!! 

 

 

 

>,.> I'm going to go take an English class now. 

markboyd26
markboyd26

 @bwatt27 sad to say elise is out of the competition. i am afraid that jessica wil be the next person packing. i love both jesicca and elise.

hrstump
hrstump moderator

 @Noelle Well, you are making it sound like it was better last year. Or the year before...

takakupo
takakupo

 @Noelle I didn't know notes came in different flavors @___@

indigo1
indigo1

 @takakupo Please Don't make me laugh! It's people like them who are keeping useless contestants around. Mark my words, he is going to win this season no matter how bad his performances are, the reason: stated above. 

mwk89
mwk89

 @hermaze07 based on Dial Idol numbers. When contestants are grouped close together, you have to take it with a grain of salt, but its showing a pretty wide margin between the top 3 (Skylar/Joshua/Hollie) and the bottom 2 (Jessica/Phillip)

takakupo
takakupo

 @mwk89  @myrsterious Dear lord, we don't talk much, but please let dial idol be correct this time and have Philip pack his bags and get the lowest amount of votes this week :] and get eliminated!!!!! MWAHAHAHAHHAAHAHHA!!!!

NathanDG
NathanDG

 @Mikhail XO Because you are cute and hot at the same time. They're just jealous! :)

cdiokno
cdiokno

 @mwk89 we'll see tomorrow, and oh boy, can't wait to see Hollie and Skylar in the bottom 2 hahah!

mwk89
mwk89

 @cdiokno that awkward moment when the bottom 2's scores keep getting further and further separated from the top 3, lol

cdiokno
cdiokno

 @mwk89 that awkward moment when Dial Idol's "bottom 2" will be tomorrow's top 2.. LOL