Tim Urban – Apologize – Video MP3 American Idol Top 24 Performance

producer's pick I should say. Not really the judges' or Simon would have vetoed his return. Total suckage. VoteforTheWorst candidate.

LOL what was he thinking. Tho i will say the lil rehersal playback part sounded much better

After watching the video. I say he needs to go out 1st. totally murdered my favorite One Republic song. This song is not for him but if people vote for his look (that I hope not) he will be back next week. =(

Thank you so much for uploading this. I knew someone who put $5 in a jukebox to hear this song all night & he looks like Tim Urban. It was uncanny to see Tim on TV. I laughed so hard my stomach hurt. THANK U!

Horrible.

He was not all that bad.. Nerves, bad song choice, He needs to come back with something he enjoys to sing and that makes him happy..........They all do as none of the guys stood out as fantastic except for Aaron Kelly

ya we all know he was put there so it'll be easy to kick him out again. i just hate the fact that they have to expose these kid's vulnerabilities and flaws on national tv -- the way they rip them to pieces and make a buck out of it. of course, the kid is to blame too for agreeing to a contract that probably pawns their souls to the devil for their share of the proverbial 15 minutes of limelight. hahaha am just sayin...

I don't think he was good in auditions and he wasn't good tonight. No idea why they brought him back unless they threw him in for the 'tween Disney votes. David Archuleta did a great rendition of this song on the Idol finale 2 years ago. I'm betting Tim is gone tomorrow. Sorry.

It wasn't as bad as the judges thought, but it wasn't great. Just mediocre. Like any average person singing the song at home.

Cute as a muffin--but his stage presence was poor--the facial expression a bit odd. Unfortunately he just is not a good singer.

Weird... Didn't like his version of Apologize... a lot more better version of that song on youtube than his performance. I'm sorry He is out!

they just put him back so he could be one of the lucky ones to exit the first week. he doesn't have a bad voice , hes just all over the place , and over doing some of the words making him spit into the mic. but theres so many better tallent they could have put threw , but at this point they have the people they want to go threw and just fill in the rest so there favorites don't get voted out in the early stages.

Simon was so right!!!! OMG, they called HIM as a replacement? I'm not liking any of the boys. What do the judges see in these singers? No personality. No voice...no charisma....bad song choice....OMG, this is horrible.

I would love to bear his children.

He's awesome to look at and I think he was fine in his natural voice but the falsetto was torture. Miscalculation on song choice but Simon was cruel.

BAD FALSETTO. He's trying too hard. He should not have sung that song if he wants to have a good impression with the judges. I think Thaddeus is waaaaaaaay better than Tim. Too bad that Thaddeus does not have much star power. Lucky for Tim, he's got the looks that might get him to the next round.

but he's sssssssssssso cute! his voice could crack the whole song and i would just think,....ahhhhhhhhhhh DREAMY

that was weird... specially on the chorus.... "its too late" his voice goes squekie >.>

Bad song choice! Yuck!