Thia Megia – Daniel – American Idol Top 11 Redux – Video MP3

Thia was boring and did not bring anything special. I don't see her as an American Idol. Come on people....let's vote on vocal talent. Her voice is beautiful but she seems one dimensional. She can only sing ballads and doesn't seem very diversed in her style. Her range is limited and her personality is not assertive enough. She cannot match the talent of others. She needs to develop her stage presence and relate to the audience. She is too shy.

Thia is like a tree laden with fruits. People usually throw rocks at trees with lots of quality fruits. She gets criticisms and gets a lot of doomsayers. Trees with nothing on them are hardly noticed and are just left alone.
Be strong, Thia. People will eventually appreciate your melodious voice. Stay sweet and just be yourself. I believe you did justice to Sir Elton John's song - Daniel. You sang it like a sister singing to and for a brother.

one thing i hate about this season is that FAVORITISM is SO OBVIOUS . RIGHT RANDY ? WTF is going on ? He's always giving reasons for Thia to be voted out .

Go Thia! We believe in you :-)

Boring, boring, boring, gone this week. Does this girl listen to herself and the other contestants? Who advises her? She doesn't make any effort to stand out. She was better in the auditions but went downhill from there. As a Filipino, I urge other Pinoys NOT to vote for her to teach her a lesson. She should have learned her lesson from the judges two episodes ago and last week, when she was in the bottom three.

My pick to win is boring the sh** outta me. She may be gone because of song choice and simply being too young. This girl can sing though!

THIA, WAKE UP, YOU CAN WIN THIS!

Love how she infused this performance with feeling. (I was 'feelin' it) Not as 'Disney Princess' as she has been in the past. Nice job!

I still don't get how she stays around. She's a good singer but has a super boring personality. No stage presence at all.

She's definitely boring, but I still like the tone of her voice :)

Scotty was oohh so BORING!!!!
Pia was another BORING.. too pageant singing.. randy should have said this to her.
Paul was way too BORING..
These 3 should be in the bottom 3.
I think Thia was the best tonight after-all american idol is SINGING competition.
Again the judges were lousy with their comments.. It's like one say something and the rest will just add up. It's like hey Can u connect the dots?

Favoritism was way too obvious.. Isn't it RANDY?

For the first time in the competition I really felt Thia. For me Haley, Casey and her were the best of the night.

Love it. omg. I dunno why. Her voice fits perfectly in this song.

The issue with Thia is that NONE of her performances have shown the vocal power or range that other performers have already in this show. Maybe it is strategy, because in her earlier performances on America's Got Talent she really had power behind her voice.

She reminds me of a mixture of Jasmine Trias and Ramiele Malubay, good singers, but singers that really never had the vocal power to capture a fan base large enough to win.

Lastly, I'm Filipino-American and my issue is that I find Filipinos generally on these boards have never been objective. Anyways, I have a tendancy to think that in the next couple of performances she will really show her vocal power or else she will find herself in the bottom shortly.

She's a studio singer. Great voice, but I wouldn't pay too much money to see her live.

i hope she will not be on the bottom 3 again! she needs to level up her performance if she wants to stay longer. the performance was still good but not that good to be on the top 5.

the problem with thia has always been her song choice.....she has a very very good tone...but her song choices...i hope she could do another "out here on my own" moment....but will america save her?

beautiful!

i'm getting kinda confused now... a few weeks back, steven tyler was talking about "perfect pitch" thing about thia's performance. and now randy was raising "pitch issues". whew! there's nothing so great about thia's song tonight, but i think she'll be safe.

being a good singer doesn't always mean being a belter. :)

Tone are good.but range are not wide enough.especially there isn't any powerful moment to impress audience.over all is okay.but didn't wow anybody.

I've loved Thia from the start. She has a beautiful voice! However I'm waiting for her to really bring it...to give me goosebumps and I haven't had that yet. I still think she has it in her so I'm gonna vote vote vote.....

She has the least performance quality. How you sell your song is even more important than how you sing it. She isn't ready for this. Great tone but always has pitch issues and can't perform to save her life. A girl so young shouldn't look like a lounge singer. And I'm not talking about moving around, what you do with your hands and eyes makes all the difference.

PINOY POWER!!! She deserves to go through! :)

Her best.

snnooooorrrrre (she always has pitch issues), very boring and clueless about the lyrics to every song she sings. She smiles in the wrong places, too. She's not mature enough for this. Her voice has promise for the future.

so boring. meh.

It was a little bit safe but that was beautiful. I love her voice.

i think it was beautiful. it's not very safe. i'm worried of the red lights. :(

That was very, very good. I hope she does not get eliminated. I do not know what the judges are seeing in Pia and Lauren.

I thought she did well!

Amazing!!!! Totally Amazing!!!

She misses her Kuya <b>(Filipino word for older brother)

Will Thia be safe singing a safe song? Asian Americans vault in to vote!</b>