Siobhan Magnus – Any Man Of Mine – Video MP3 American Idol Top 6

Siobhan is entertaining and I get a real kick out of her - - but if I close my eyes and listen, it's just awful. She'd be good in Rocky Horror Picture Show tho.

Still not loving her song choices, but this is a step BACK in the right direction. These high notes are what she does best, and the slower songs should be like the ones she did during the semifinals. Not Suspicious Minds... the judges have thus far manipulated her by telling her not to do what is HER... so hopefully now she's starting to change direction and will do her instead of the judges.

She scares me! Eww this is horrible, she totally ruined my favorite shania song!

Oh my was she terrible or what? The song was SO easy, and yet she totally killed it with the screaming (in a very bad way). She needs to go now.

Wow. The suckage coming off this performance could create a black hole. Is LA still where it's supposed to be this morning?

Did she remind anyone else of Flo, the waitress from the old TV show "Alice"? LMAO.

God. Awful.

Please make it stop.

IMO, she should have waited a year or two to audition for Idol. Her voice is hollow in her lower register, like she doesn't know how to support the lower tones. Her upper range is beautiful, but I found it unpleasant to listen to the first half of this song. It also seemed like she was a half beat behind the music. Maybe it's because she was doing all the running around. I really, really wanted to love this performance, but think she was trying to do too much and got lost in the whole thing.

It's the NASAL Country Week Night. She is having a baby. Sooooooo BAD, cmon tone deaf people admit it was sooooooo loud and just shouting.

She has yet to display what kinda artist she wants to be, she did however remove country from the list.

If the girl didnt scream, she'd have gone home along time ago.

Ive concluded that she puts ev1 asleep within 10 secs then wakes em up in the last 10-so no one hears the dreaded 1:40 inbetween. She has absolutely no shot at a record. Musicals are her only shot after idol

Even if they say that "Crytal and Lee are untouchable" well, i dont believe that statement.!

Voters has the power to decide.. So Siobhan fans lets vote ALL THE WAY.!

One thing, i hope siobhan fans noticed that her fb account has aaron's no.!
WTF???

Good Luck tomorrow.!

Not idol worthy - sorry

Andrea (67.1) is right.she has hit some high notes that were good and hadn't been bashed every time but sometimes she could use some voice control like Buffy (76) suggested. She hasn't been bashed EVERY time for the high notes but enough times to be noticed. All singers will hit a high straining note and f they are already famous...then its great and we praise them. But if you're just starting out you are horrid. Love her.

i love siobhan a million times!!!

Siobhan is a unique and gifted singer with range and art house appeal. I actually like her high notes but this song, not so much. She was my early favourite when she sang Wicked Game, House Of The Rising Sun and Paint It Black. Maybe constant and contradictory critiques from Simon and Kara has affected her confidence and performance. Some of her song choices have not been the best. I would still like to see her in the Top 2.
A shout out to Rickey: Thanks for all your hard work downloading audios and videos of AI performances. I've visited many AI blogs and sites and I think yours is the most user friendly and the best.

She is unique in every aspect! In a very good way! She's definitely Season 9's pride! She's different!

She will win! Mark my words guys!

I'm ready to buy her records!

She will be the next American Idol!

the best performance of the night!

the most unforgettable performance!

wooooooooooooot

OMG Siobhan was terrible, she sounded like a wounded animal out there, talk about a "Twain Wreck" that was bad. Best of the night was Casey James by far, and yeah, Crystal was boring and slow FOR ONCE but she made that song more country than Shania ever did and it is after all country week. Lee was pretty bad also and he is usually one of my favorites. All I have to say is the judges need to get to the point with Siobhan and get her voted off, she is ruining the show for me at this point plus I am getting embarrassed for her, she needs some voice control lessons ASAP.

ABOUT DAMN TIME!! Siobhan is BACK! About time the judges give her the much deserved praise she never gets! LOVE YOU SIOBHAN!! been voting non-stop on both your numbers!

Vote for her and send Big Mike home!

Every week I want to like her, but soooooo many bum notes. Oof.

The best!!!

Siobhan is back! This girl can SING! It's not enough to talk about it though, come on we have to vote!

I LOVE IT, she is so over the top!

she has so many influences in her singing and yet sound weird and like anything else.
She is the bomb! This girl just need to get a good producer like dr luke and she can get a spot that is being used by poor singers like kesha

Siobhan has an amazing voice but for some reason I just don't like her style. Last week's dramatic presentation was like torture listening to her. She did do a better job this week but she seems like she's too tense when singing. It's hard to listen to her. The other singers are much easier to listen to. No offense, JMO.

I am not a fan of Shania Twain song but I like this girl, she's always full of surprises, you'll never know what you're gonna get, something like a box of chocolate (borrow it from Forrest Gump)!

"diaf" nailed it. If she hits high notes, she is screaming and when she lays back, she is boring. She can't win. But even Simon did not completely bash her tonight for the high notes. He only said "The screaming in the end may have gone a little bit…" and he turned it into an almost polite ribbing of her.(She COULD try hitting high notes a bit softer and let her sweet voice control it a bit) The other 3 judges did not even care for his ribbing her....they loved her. Kara's saying, "Guess who’s back? Siobhan!" I have to reply..."She never went anywhere!" LOVED her....one of the top 2 tonight......she will be back next week.

She wasn't technically perfect through the whole song tonight like she usually is but that is a very good thing in my opinion because instead she rocked the house down!!!! High energy, growls, screams, high notes, smiles and 100% pure entertainment. I had NO DOUBT that she was going to bring it tonight.
I LOVE SIOBHAN!!
And I love the fire and attitude she brought tonight.
A+ IMO

Siobhan was the best! She is showing everybody she is the next AI! Simon and Kara don't like her but they know they can't say bad things anymore because that was not working. Now, they are trying the opposite so that people can relax and don't vote.
Vote for Siobhan!!!!! She is the best!!

if she left the screaming out it would have been perfect and was she singing that song to blake in the front row? i just noticed that blake was sitting behind the judges.

UGH... this was not a good performance. How on earth did she get so much praise??
It's like she was out of breath during the faster parts, and of course her awful scream. It wasn't as bad as previous screams, but still just not necessary and SO gimmicky

why are all the crystal fans leaving there negative comments.this is a siobhan magnus comment blog.lovers and fans only.

get down to the show tonight.
1.siobhan,who else. she is back.not her greatest,but the best vocals tonight.
2.casey.made the right song choice.
3.lee.ok,but not his best .
4.mike.took a tough song,and did ok.
5.crystal.sorry crystral fans,but i call them as i see,and of course hear them.pitchy,and missed notes.
6.aaron,not too good,borderline ok.probably going home,or possibly mike.

Siobhan can makes feel the people... she can be a chameleon.. i think she want show that.. In my Opinion Crytal always bored and never connected with the audience, she sings whit her eyes closed... she is not trasmitted absolutely nothing and nobody tells nothing about it.. the judges are so weird this season.. so partial.. siobhan has pernality.. (Y)

Go Siobhan..!! xD

She killed it at the end! Much better song choice than last week. And she even looked a bit like Shania tonight. Just from this video (I haven't seen the entire show yet), it looked like Shania was looking anxious because she was rooting for Siobhan, not because she was appalled at the rendition.

Did Siobhan know she could walk around and interact with the audience while still singing the song, or is this new found confidence? Siobhan works to entertain the audience every week, and this was really showcased this week - she put on quite a performance!

She was AMAZING::::Not much you could do with that song anyways! All the haters here bag on adam lambert also...Kris Who??

The funniest thing is that she managed to pull off a PUNK COUNTRY GENRE

I generally like Siobhan, except for a couple of 'off key' words during this performance it was quite 'cool' - but then completely spoilt it with her finish!

yey! go siobhan! at least there's one performance among the bunch that's upbeat.

I remember Mandisa getting eliminated with this song. I hope she doesn't get the same fate. wooh!

Good song choice...compared to the previous weeks but it seems that she's lost a bit of the Siobhan magic.

I AM SO PROUD OF YOU SIOBHAN.AFTER 2 WEEKS OF LISTENING TO THEM DOGGING HER.SHE WAS FABULOUS ANS HAS MY VOTE.I LOVE HER-SHE IS THE ONLY ONE AFTER THIS PERFORMANCE THAT WOWED ME.WAY TO GO!!!!

Wow, I didn't get that at all. The beginning of the song was a total trainwreck. I was completely shocked that the judges praised that. She is a beautiful girl, though!

YES!!! SIOBHAN IS BACK!!!! THAT WAS AMAZING!! FIRE! FIRE!

I don't like it. I don't get it either. Maybe becos I love the orginal so much (esp. the tempo and how Shania performed it). Siobhan sang as if she was losing her breath, running from here to there. She didn't sing the words clearly. I like the big note however, but it was like a little too much.

All in all, the show was great tonight. Shania did well with her mentor job. I love Aaron. His performance brought me to tears.

Tomorrow's gonna be real tough. My guess: Aaron is gonna be sent home, though I'd like the spot to be Big Mike or Siobhan.