- Previous story Haley Reinhart – I Who Have Nothing – American Idol Top 4 – Video MP3
- Next story Lauren Alaina – Trouble – American Idol Top 4 – Video MP3
I can't stand Scotty. His singing is that mix of contrived twang and deep-throated moaning that passes for talent in male country music stars. He is too young and way too unoriginal. Still, this is American Idol after all.... talent is likely the least important factor.
Would have liked to see him do something a bit more serious. He might as well have done Charlie Brown. The top of his range sounds a bit to forced, but he does entertain as goofy as it is.
Omg he's d worst of d lot even from top 24 on. No range, no style, no vibratto, no way. Just a silly hillbilly. In top 4, they really have it in for Halley. How could they have said dat abt hAlley n sing such praises of stupid Scotty. Jennifer n randy have a agenda. So disapppointed in dem
I hope you go home tomorrow. I agree with all of the comments above. Please let's end this...facial expressions and the way he holds the microphone is plain silly.
This was my second favorite performance of the evening. I love when the kid uses different colors of his voice and acts a bit insane.
What is it you guys are so afraid of with Scotty? That he actually knows how to perform and make the audience absolutely love him? We do and he is a superstar already, and in six months when he's driving a new sport car and making funny faces all the way to the bank, you'll will still be sitting around with a computer in your lap trying to find someone else to hate. Love this guy!!!!!!
That was bad. He doesn't sing well; he's a joke. Only he's boring and self-righteous joke. Steven said he was like Pat Boone; I was thinking Jim Neighbors. Anyway, yuck. Yuck yuck yuck.
Is cocking his head to one side what makes his voice so deep? Please, please go home tomorrow! I can't take him anymore!
He totally hammed it up. My daughter said he looked like a chicken! He was much better in the rehearsal. Cracked me up how he was scared to look Gaga in the face!
Musically, that was not entertaining at all. Scotty is boring already. I know he's country but there are lot of things a country singer could do, so that they will not to bore his/her fans (try to look Carrie Underwood and Taylor Swift).
The judges are not credible anymore. Scotty's voters should wake up because Scotty is not that great!
How cheesy and corny was that whole performance? Times like this I miss Simon. I believe he would have ripped him a new one just for the facial expressions alone.