Paul McDonald – Maggie Mae – American Idol Top 24 – Video MP3

Did you see his little break interview? "I hope you get it?" Oh, I get it all right!
A scam for non musically inclined tone deaf folk.
Nasal under breath raspy. Oooh! How original.
Rod Steward, raspy, though could carry pitch tone and had at least some strength in the presentation of his voice.
And this "tripping" all over and around the stage - OMG - Hillarious!
Paul McDonald! You are unique all right! Musically talented? Give me a break!
I certainly wish him the best in life. But for Gods sake, please get eliminated.
My musical senses regarding Idol destroyed each time I see that smile, which portaits to me that even he can't believe the company he is in.

tiny, tiny voice. this is weak sauce.

At first I didn't care for Rod Stewart. Thought he was just a face. When I learned he had written his songs his stock value went up. I Googled Paul McDonald & learned he writes & plays his own stuff (very good stuff indeed). I think he's the real deal.

paul just gets what music is- woulda killed it beyond belief if he used a mic stand

He needs to work on hitting the notes and I'm a little bothered that his singing voice is so different from his speaking voice - like he is trying to imitate a style. But he was probably one of the more entertaining. He will likely be around for a while.

The best of the night!

I want to do him but I really do not want to hear him sing. Is that so wrong?

Love him!

He sounds like he is out of breath through much of the song. Not feeling this guy at all.

Dude just doesn't impress me. I think people will grow tired of him. The smiling thing is annoying. Sorry :(

I LOVE LOVE LOVE PAUL!!!

*just

Really??!! You just like him because he's good looking, 'cause if not he is a Kris Allen copy, with the difference Kriss had a special voice. Paul doesn't touch my heart but I'm sure Ricky Martin on Elton John love him. Ask them

I thought he smiled and acted happy through a song that is not a smiley happy song - this song is more serious as the guy is having to leave his love and Paul just made a joke of the whole thing.

The music was too overpowering. His voice was so muffled by it I thought.

To me, he's way too unique, and it's not good. His body language is really2 disturbing I think. But I think he deserves a place in top 12

I feel in love with his voice tonight. Go, Paul. I'm voting for you!

Reminds me of the time Jason Castro sang daydream and charmed the socks of errrbody. :)

I haven't like Paul... until tonight. I am totally changing my opinion on him. Tonight, he proved that his subtle style works on the Idol stage. I really liked it!