Paige Miles sings Smile by Charlie Chaplin on the American Idol Top 16
Rickey: I’m throwing her under the bus.
Randy Jackson: It just didn’t work, man.
Ellen DeGeneres: That song is supposed to be inspiring. It was just sad and heavy.
Kara DioGuardi: Tonight was not the night to do that?
Simon Cowell: The arrangement was just awful. This could be the end of the road.
Watch the video here: