American Idol

Paige Miles – Against All Odds – Video MP3 American Idol Top 11

Paige Miles sings Against All Odds on the American Idol Top 11

Download: Against All Odds | Video

Rickey: OMG WE NEED TO SAVE PAIGE MILES! BDND! She cannot die! Save her! Paige! 1-866-IDOLS-02

Randy Jackson: Honestly, that was terrible. It was terrible.

Ellen DeGeneres: You didn’t fall down (heels).

Kara DioGuardi: Somewhere along the line you stopped competing. It was the worst vocal … of the season.

Simon Cowell: There were like five of you singing that song. You are going to be in serious trouble tonight. That song just killed you.

Watch video here:


Photo courtesy of FOX/FremantleMedia Ltd.

Source americanidol.com

American Idol Against All OddsAmerican Idol 9MP3Paige MilesTop 11Video

Got Something to Add?

59 comments
JJ
JJ

I thought that paige had one of the best voices. Some people at that time should have been booted off before her. She just a little bit more time cuz andrew garcia had like 10 chances to outdo his audition and paige had only like 3 chances. she was treated VERY unfairly in my strong opinion.

hesterprune
hesterprune

Of course Paige's performance was bad. She didn't have her voice back yet. What was Miley's excuse?

Monjie
Monjie

That was... bad.

Marie
Marie

She sounded so tired and awful. Please do us all a favor America and send her home already!

Quinton
Quinton

I should pick PAIGE songs. She's making Horrible picks. She should get like BIG MIKE and stick to one Genre and RIDE that to AI9 Finale.

Kanuto
Kanuto

don't save her.. she is not deserving to be save! :D

Stefan
Stefan

Her belting scared my budgies. =/

I didn't think it was THAT bad....wasn't great though. But perhaps I'm biased cuz I adore Paige's personality. But really, her singing appeared to freak out my budgies, and the performance scares birds..that's not good!

Quinton
Quinton

!985 #1 Classic "HOW WILL I KNOW" by Whitney Houston would have been a perfect song for Paige.

nlkt
nlkt

gosh it's Smile Part 2. i don't think ballads suit her.

TankGirl
TankGirl

Rickey... STOP with the save pleas!!

it's getting as bad as VFTW

GAWD this season Sucks

Jay
Jay

Why does she keep on singing with her lower range when she has a higher range?

Fan # 1
Fan # 1

It was really bad. I hate saying that because I really like Paige. But, I think that she is going home.

Also, everyone talking about Haeley. I really thought she was GREAT and that she was better then a lot of the people on here. I thought she was treated very unfairly. But, that's just my opinion.

American Idol Fan
American Idol Fan

Whoa, she butchered the song. Hands down the worst version of the song eva!

ron
ron

the start was bad... but it wasn't totally that bad o.o

newginafets
newginafets

definitely GOING HOME, or SHOULD GO HOME!!

anoni
anoni

ok that was bad...

a Rose
a Rose

Paige is adorable and the shoes rocked. Vocally? The laryngitis really worked for her last week. This week? Not so much. Still, I think she'll be around for another week, I really do. :-( First of all, she's the last of the divas and the judges were really hard on her tonight. Never underestimate the pity vote.

samson
samson

why oh why did she pick that song that has been so overdone... scott savol among others sang it... and to top it off she did really awful with it... i think she will be leaving....

Laura
Laura

It was PAINFUL!!!!!! That is one of my favorite songs (the Phil Collins version) and even if she was trying a different version, it must have been by a band called We Suck. I haven't watched any of the other performances yet but wow, that was bad. And I had such high hopes for her.............

Justin
Justin

I feel so bad for her, cuz she is great, but it's kinda her fault cuz she obviously doesn't do too well with the slow songs... yet she picked one anyway... a boring one at that... :(

Alex and Lilly
Alex and Lilly

I seriously want a good black diva comes back to this show. I was terribly disappointed by Lil Rounds lasts eason and the same thing pretty much hapened with Paige. Where's the Fantasia, LaToya, Treyce, Mandisa, Paris, Melinda, LaKisha, and Tamyra factor? Where did they go?

druzilla
druzilla

Terrible but I fear most that she'll squeak through because the judges were so hard on her.

No one should sing this song. Jim C. tweets this was the 7th time it's been performed on Idol... most of *any* song.

Lynn
Lynn

First and Third performances stunk up the joint. Lee was better but not much...what is wrong with these contestants. They only have 100 zillion songs to chose from. Woe is Idol.

Quinton
Quinton

Why PAIGE. Out of all songs you chose that song.

Sing Beyonce or something. DAMN! I'm so mad at you right now.

Agree Rickey! Save the black diva!!

ohreli
ohreli

NOT the "worst vocal of the season"! I think "Smile" was probably worse.

Fabian
Fabian

There is something about Paige I really like but sadly it wasnt this performance .....barring a major disaster I think this is end of the line for her...although listening to Tim as I type this Im thinking how the hell did Alex Lambert get eliminated over this guy.......I think eliminations over the next few weeks will be very predictable......Im looking forward to aaron next and I hope he does the country version of Aerosmith song

merly
merly

I think Kara is wrong, that was not the worst vocal of the season, It was not good but it surely wasn't the worst of the season

Jobe
Jobe

You can't save everyone, let her go...on second thought, I'm listening to Tim....uh...

DOUBLE ELIMINATION TUESDAY!!!!

Quinton
Quinton

Simon will save her tomorrow night if she's Eliminated.
He was going to save Paige last week, but she was safe.

KatA
KatA

That would be an awesome song for her. I can totally hear her singing that and doing really well with it. Tonight was just really unfortunate. She has the vocals but she has got to pick better songs. She is running out of chances if she wasn't knocked off with tonight's performance.

TankGirl
TankGirl

What's Diva-y about Paige? she's got more of a rock vibe thing sorta...

Quinton
Quinton

Rickey is doing the right thing. Thanks for the Movement!

Save the Black Diva Movement is Growing by the day!!

Paul
Paul

thats an overstatement

bfashion58
bfashion58

Just because Siobhan sings an R&B song doesn't mean she could make it on an R&B station or get the R&B crowd to buy her music. She sings the white version of an R&B song, which is hard to explain to most of you unless you are a true R&B listner. Siobhan has a decent voice, well actually a good voice, but Crystal is far better.

Nooyet
Nooyet

Why would they keep Angela? She went through too much crap in her life to even deal with the show. I think its good they let her go that way she could be with her family since her mom is missing. At least next year, Angela (who will be 30 years old; too old for idol, young enough for xfactor) can do x factor.

And why cant Siobhan be our black diva for this season?

merly
merly

If Idol kept angela, there's be a lot of crying on the show, I think that girl is too overdramatic

Quinton
Quinton

agree so much!

IF IDOL KEPT ANGELA MARTIN FOR SEASON 9. WE WONT HAVE THIS DAMN PROBLEM.

bfashion58
bfashion58

Sorry Quinton, but she is not the black diva because she sings pop music. I would never expect to hear any of her music on an R&B station unless she makes it after this show and switches to R&B music.

No save, that was just plain horrible even if she was still sick. I don't think I've ever heard anyone singing that bad on this show and I've lost count of all the bad singers.

Bottom line, this show doesn't want anymore R&B singers. The days of Ruben, Fantasia, Tamyra, Melinda, J-Hud and even Angela Martin.......... are clearly over!

AI Fan
AI Fan

I actually thought it was the worst vocal ever.. just in general.

merly
merly

Haeley Vaughn, Part of the Top 24 this season, she did not make it to the top 12 though

Daisy B
Daisy B

Whoops ~ I remember who Haeley was now! I was thinking Hayley Scarnatto (aka Legs) from S6.

Daisy B
Daisy B

Haeley who? There wasn't a Haeley this season was there?

merly
merly

Haeley, I Want To Hold Your Hand

Jobe
Jobe

Who was worse?

Nooyet
Nooyet

Kara is stupid. Tim Urban's "Apologize" and anything by Haeley was the worst of the season. Unless Kara meant as of the top 12. Oh well, Kara is a bee-utch.

Lynn
Lynn

Yeah, a double elimination is in order. But let's hold that thought...it may need to be a triple elimination before the show is over.