American Idol

Nicki Minaj – American Idol Judge Candidate at Center of Cola Wars

Could Nicki Minaj be the next pop star turned American Idol Judge?  THR claims their sources say yes, but not if long time Idol sponsor Coke has anything to say about it.

According to THR, Fox executives are dead set on Minaj being a part of the season 12 judging team, but Minaj’s gig as a spokesperson for Pepsi might throw a wrench in the works.  Seems long time Idol sponsor Coke is none to happy about the idea of having the new face of Pepsi on the judging panel.

The article also alleges that the exec’s ideal panel is currently Mariah, Nicki, a country star (Keith Urban being the current front runner) and a latin star (Enrique Iglesias being the top choice for that spot), with Randy’s role being reduced to that of a mentor.

That would certainly be an interesting panel.  Minaj would fulfill both the need for a “current” star and replace (and probably exceed) the cray cray that left the panel with Steven Tyler.  Adding a country and a Latin performer would add some welcome diversity to the panel.  I’m not a huge Nicki Minaj fan, but I think I actually like the direction they are headed with this, assuming the rumors are true anyway, or maybe I’m just that desperate to see the end of the Randy Jackson era….

From THR:

 According to a source with close ties to the show, longtime rivals Coke and Pepsi are at war again, but not about market share, rather over hitmaker Nicki Minaj. The rapper and singer, whose colorful, cartoon-like style has made her among the most successful new acts of the last three years, is at the top of the list for the open seat on season 12 of Idol, but as the new face of Pepsi, an endorsement deal which includes commercials along with touring and album promo, Idol sponsor Coke is none too thrilled at the prospect. The leading soda company has been an Idolpartner since season one, at a cost of $26 million per year, according to reports. The show ran into a similar problem when longtime sponsor Ford got wind of judge Jennifer Lopez‘s commerical deal with Fiat.  

If Fox and FremantleMedia execs have their way, this year’s panel would consist of Minaj, previously announced judge Mariah Carey, a country star (the leading candidate is Keith Urban, says an insider) and a Latin artist (Enrique Iglesias is believed to be the No. 1 choice). In March, Minaj showed genuine empathy towards those who compete on Idol, telling THR special correspondent and Idol alum Didi Benami, “It’s very difficult to be picked apart. That rejection thing is heavy.”

Nicki Minaj - American Idol Judge Candidate at Center of Cola Wars

photo credit: mypinkfriday.com

American Idol American IdolNicki Minaj

Got Something to Add?

7 comments
fuckhead
fuckhead

Really, this person is not suitable to judge other talent.  She doesn't have enough to spare.

thelimoboy
thelimoboy

I'm a big Nicki fan and even I think it's slightly weird that she's being considered as a judge. She's crazy and she's current, but I don't think she would have it in her to be mean to contestants and I don't know how she'd balance being a serious mentor with her personality. Like Pink said in a recent interview, if judges were actually honest, people would hate them. The only person who actually gets away with it is Simon Cowell (Piers Morgan and other people unsuccessfully try to be like Simon). 

As much as I like her, I don't see her being a judge :/

Joystickenvy
Joystickenvy

@thelimoboy being too nice could definitely be a problem....i.e. Ellen  her personality seems a little big to fit into a four person judging panel, but the trainwreck potential is just outstanding

fuckhead
fuckhead

So far every AI judge has been a talented and successful person. I have not liked them all.

fuckhead
fuckhead

@Joystickenvy Oh shite.  I forgot about Paula completely.  That was a no talent.  Dancing does not count here.

Joystickenvy
Joystickenvy

@WaynoCoaster I think Minaj has at least as much singing talent as Paula or J. Lo and she's probably rather more qualified to judge singers than Ellen was.  Which isn't to say she would be top of my list to join the panel.  I think her personality could lead to some fabulous train wreck moments, but I have my doubts about her value as a judge.  However, I thought Ellen would be wonderful based on her guest judging on SYTYCD and she was terrible, mostly due to how obviously uncomfortable she was in the role.  Simon is really the only judge that I think ever gave much in the way of valuable critique, though he was often so over the top with his remarks that it got lost.  Some of the others have had entertainment value at times, but didn't add much else.