Haley Reinhart – You and I – American Idol Top 5 – Video MP3
Haley Reinhart sings You and I on American Idol Top 5
Rickey: An unreleased Lady Gaga song!
Steven Tyler: That’s a beautiful thing.
Jennifer Lopez: I’m not so sure that was the best advise to sing an unreleased song.
Randy Jackson: I’m not sure if that was a great song. It’s so risky.
Watch video here:
Download MP3: MediaFire
Showbiz News from our Partners
Got Something to Add?
Haley keeps surprising with her wide vocal range and increasingly confident performances. She is never boring! Keep her going!
There's a reason why it was unreleased. But that could be her first single. With the right production, it could be a hit. Was Haley a Hooters?
I was not Haley fans at the beginning of this show.
But she grows a lot during the past few weeks and all I can say, I am her big fans now.
Her best performance in Idol. She's really brave! I don't know why the judges hate her. So sad she's underrated...I still hope for a Haley-James finale!
I just don´t want Haley to win this thing. She is such a poser with her sitting poses and looking sexy. She bugs me so much.
Lauren really did so much better tonight!
This girl bores me the moment the camera lands on her. And what nerve singing an unreleased Gaga song. Who wants to go home more this week? Haley or Jacob?
The judges made it out to be horrible when it was just as decent as Lauren and James and Scotty. Yeah it wasnt a moment like they wanted it to be but it was better than what they gave it credit for
I saw Lauren sit down on the steps a couple of times. Once for no apparent reason near the end of a song.
Speaking of posing, did you like it when Lauren pulled the non-audience-member audience member up on stage to sing to him?
Haley has a very unique quality to her voice and she is creative in style.
Lauren's persona strikes me as she being cocky with an atitude that is not impressionable. Lauren is rather boring and doesn't really bring anything new to a song. She is good, considering her age but needs more experience.
"She should be honored that Lady Gaga gave her an unreleased song."
She was. Maybe you meant Randy and J-Lo should have been honored as they're the ones who weren't impressed.
Since you have so much mad respect for Lady Gaga, I bet it drove you up the wall when she guest mentored and declared Haley's singing to be "amazing."
She should be honored that Lady Gaga gave her an unreleased song....who else gets that special treatment?