Haley Reinhart – I Who Have Nothing – American Idol Top 4 – Video MP3
Haley Reinhart sings I Who Have Nothing on American Idol Top 4
Rickey: This was Jordin Sparks’ winning song. Lady Gaga wanted Haley to go psycho and dramatic.
Steven Tyler: You just Reinharted yourself in the middle of next week.
Jennifer Lopez: Look what you’re capable of baby.
Randy Jackson: Baby, you just had a moment right here.
Watch video here:
Download MP3: MediaFire
Got Something to Add?
This fit the sadness is Haley's voice so well. I actually think this was the one time that GaGa was spot on with encouraging the emotion. And that breath right before the end, was perfect. It fit the song so well. The only part I didn't like was when her voice "drizzled" down right before the second verse.
Scotty is a good 'one trick pony' Randy Travis wannabe... Lauren also has 'country star' written all over her. James is a great singer, but enough with the screaming high notes song after song after song after . . .. pass me the ear plugs! I of those remaining, Haley is the most versatile, original, and week after week grabs my heart and my emotions with her amazing vocals and beautiful appearance. Haley's the one
Night and day difference between her two performances. The first one I ignored and kept working on the computer I was building. The second one I was stunned, jaw dropped, with chills running up my neck. My vote goes to the best performance of the night and is not influenced by the worst performance of the night. I would rather have a 50% chance at seeing something awesome than a 100% chance of seeing something mediocre.
Lauren on Haley: "She has the best voice on this show & she gets the most criticism. I deserve a lot more criticism. I'm Haley's #1 fan" :')
Half of twitter is HATING on Haley's attitude tonight, the other half is HATING on the judges for throwing Haley under the bus.
<b>Haley FTW!!! Scotty and Haley FINAL TWO!!! I have been a fan of this Mariah Carey look-a-like from teh first time she was int eh bottom 3. I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE HER VOICE!!!! </b>
i'm sorry, but she just gets on my nerves with nearly every performance, since she consistently over-sings each song, and gets too growly. If she would tune it down a notch or so, and not try to "interpret" the song too much, she would come across as much more listenable.
Best performance of the night--sexy, creepy in keeping with the stalker-vibe of the song, and sung with passion. She was awesome.
I sure hope she stays around.
I don't really understand these effusive comments. Why not keep it real?
Here is Shirley Bassey: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmOCDc3xLCs
Here is Tom Jones: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQnsN3um-iQ&feature=related
Here is a Swedish dude: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7QsLlvtOvA&feature=related
Patrizio Buanne: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vuqAWjXvOSM&feature=related
The Wiz song composer Luther Vandross and Martha Washington: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=urCn2xIXOs0
It seems that nobody can touch Scotty. Even a performance as good as this. He's always at the top of the ranking, even if he performs bad. Maybe the judges don't want to add fuel to the fire by criticizing Scotty too much as that might trigger sympathy votes for the already popular Scotty. This song was a hundred times better than Scotty's first song. What was that, again? What was his second song? Forgettable, no?
Randy and JLo, you two are simply jealous of Haley. Randy annoys me so much with his non-sense craps. I can no longer stand these 2 and I'm glad Steven stepped in for once!
Haley did a great job with the song and her performance clearly was better than James' right before that... no way "James set the bar" and Haley didn't surpass it (as JLo implied).
I'm living in the West Coast and I can't call in yet, so I'll start the online voting for Haley RIGHT NOW!
For those of you with At&t and unlimited text messaging you can set up a contact group for 10 contacts an make all of them 1-866-436-5702 and send the word VOTE to that group and keep resending over and over and over again. This is called mass texting and it is the best way to keep Haley around give it a try. I once did this when I checked my bill I had over 32,000 votes in one night haha.
No offense Rickey, but don't save her. PLEASE VOTE FOR LAUREN ALAINA! EVER SINCE CASEY WAS VOTED OFF SHE WAS MY NEW FAVORITE.
Best of the night... even if she screamed a bit in the first song. This one was 10x better than what anybody else did tonight.
She's never sounded so confident and sure of herself. I think the criticism from her first song fueled so much angst in her the only way the song could've been better was if fire came out of the palms of her hands.
at least Haley changed up I who have nothing from Jordin's version.....i think both are great in there own way...
Lauren completely copied Carrie's version of trouble....
It was probably the best performance so far this season (Which really isn't saying much if) but DEF not the best performance of all time.
Really? Ever heard of Kelly Clarkson? Fantasia? Carrie Underwood's "Alone" performance??? How insulting.
Do you keep it real after other contestants have performed and post links to professionals that have done the same song?
In any case, Haley's performance stands up to everyone you linked. And they didn't have to perform after being toyed with emotionally and reduced to tears minutes before.
I agree, it seems I don't remember anyone elses songs except for Haley's. House of the Rising Sun, You and I, I who have nothing, and Earth song, I remember them all and sing it to my self everyday\
Uh, no! I think Pia should be in the place of Scotty or James or even Lauren, NOT the only talented singer left (which is Haley...if you were too slow to catch that).
I don't think that's Pia actually next to Paul. There is a brunette there, but looking carefully at her face, she is someone else...someone younger.
It doesn't matter anyway. Pia will be more successful than Haley, post Idol.
That was Paul's girlfriend Nikki Reed, lol. Pia wasn't there. :) They are both brunettes so I see why it was confusing. I think Casey , Paul and Julie Zorrilla were the only AI 10 contestants there last night.