Haley Reinhart – Fallin – American Idol Top 24 – Video MP3

Yes, I felt that her dancing around was kind of a turn off, and came across a little egotistically, but I think she is a bit insecure. Her growling actually didn't bother me so much, but I thought it was a little too much. She definitely has a soulful voice and I think the tone is very very good. I enjoyed it a lot, and I think I enjoyed that more than the original. I liked her interpretation of the song and her rifts were numerous but done really well and fit. She has a good ear for the music. She feels the music in her body, she feels what she is saying.

But I wish she didn't dance so sexily just to get votes. I'd rather she let her voice do the work for her. She's a dark horse. She is good, but her personality may not be authentic enough.

She strikes me as fake, a lot of just phony facial expressions during judges reactions and what not.

Very campy performance...and the facial expressions are priceless. The voice is okay, nothing special.

<b>Can someone please give her a laxative! Her growling is so annoying it sounds like she's constipated. And she growls for every song!!!!!!!</b>

Definitely my favorite. Dialidol isn't in her favor though (but then again I'm not trusting it because look at it... that just can't be right). Haley's my favorite this year. I really hope she'll make it through to the Top 13.

I never knew Fallin' was such a carefree happy song about how wonderful life was. Or at least that's what her smile kept on trying to tell me, no matter what the lyrics actually meant.

She is so hot!!!!!VOTE VOTE VOTE

My favorite tonight so far!! I don't get why Randy was so down on her performance. I thought it was amazing!