Haeley Vaughn – I Wanna Hold Your Hand – Video MP3 American Idol Top 24 Performance
Haeley Vaughn sings “I Wanna Hold Your Hand” by the Beatles on the American Idol 9 Top 24
Ellen DeGeneres: You just shine. I enjoyed it.
Kara DioGuardi: You have fun. You gotta work on your technical abilities.
Randy Jackson: The top of the vocals is just not as pleasing.
Simon Cowell: I thought it was verging on terrible. You are like a windup doll that never stops smiling.
I LOVED THIS. GO HAELEY! Simon I disagree with you. Haeley was great.
Watch the video here:
You should follow me on Twitter here for up to the minute American Idol updates!
Showbiz News from our Partners
Got Something to Add?
It wasn't as pitchy as simon said it was. She is actually a VERY good singer. I think next week she needs to pick a big country song and sing it really well and then she will be fine.
I like that she was one of the very FEW that actually did something different with a song, and she looked like she had a great time performing. She wasn't afraid of the stage. She wasn't great, but I don't think she was as bad as the judges said.
I thought she was TERRIFIC. It's the rawness and freshness of her sound that makes her so wonderful, much like Taylor Swift.
I luv luv luved it! They were way over critical. There was something so current and fresh about her performance. I also don't want her to stop smiling...saying she should stop smiling too much was a overly critical in a mean-spirited way. I luv her smile. Ellen's comments were on target this time. God knows, you can never go wrong with a smile.
I actually liked it. It's one of the performances I remember. Though she is too smiley throughout the whole song. But she can work on that.
THE REST OF THEM WERE SOUND ALIKES...I LOVE HER RENDITION AND COUNTRY TWIST ON THIS BEATLES SONG... YES.. she needs some training and control tips -- she is ONLY 16 and has a really Looooooong career in her future... " the first Black Female country TOP CHART artist is on her way! She is Great to not have any pro coaching--- that will come later-- I LOVE HER! YO GO HAELEY !!!
Is it a good sign when you draw Sanjaya comparisons for your likeability sans vocal ability on your first performance? Yes? No?
I thought she would be here for a long time but after that I would be surprise if she is still here after thursday
All of these girls were bad - no wonder they didn't select Angela Martin - she would have blown them out of the water. So sad for idol. Hayley wasn't that bad. She sang better than most of the ladies. Crystal - throwback. We need something fresh.
It was a little weird in the middle but overall it was different and fun. I'd like to hear more from her next week.
I really liked the arrangement, it was kind of what you'd expcect Jason Mraz to do to it, but her voice just doesnt cut it.
I rarely want to like someone based on their personality; but I felt that way about her... but Jebus Krist... That was worse than anything Sanjaya ever did.
She killed the song,it was terrible, i know it's not my fave beatles song but come on if you cant make it half as good as beatles did it, then dont. She spoiled this song and now i have to listen to this song(original version) 10 times to be be neutral about the song again.
Rickey, are you serious? This girl sounded so bad, she wrecked a classic!
I dvr'ed Idol and I had to fast forward through her song after listening to half of it.
Her voice and arrangement were hard to follow, it was painful.
I was disapointed and I liked the whole "country" thing she had going.
I had high hopes for a lot of the girls tonight, w/all the bragging it was a let down.
Haeley really was the worst of the worst.
Note to Ellen, "hot mess" is NOT a good thing.
This performance was HORRIBLE!! Simon was correct!!
She was a waste of time! Angela Martin should have had this spot.
I don't think she has a good voice, but there is something about her that I just LOVE! She has so much light within her, and I think people will definitely vote for her.
When the judges said, "technical" they were being kind. I had my 7.1 speakers going and girlfriend was HORRIBLE. Another issue which made me put her on mute, Haeley has a very bad lisp when singing. The enunciation of the words came across horribly and she definitely needs serious work. I agree with everything Simon said, Kara and Randy were being nice, and Ellen was too generous. That performance was a mess.
loved her from the jump,beautiful voice with super range.would benefit her to work on her control,but i believe its due to her age.coupled with a magnetic smile and a unique lisp,she has something that i'm loving.hopefully we'll get to see more of her,and she will be able to make progress to stay on as long as possible,if not win.i'm rootin' for her.
It was def a different arrangement. The song has never been a fave of mine....too simpleminded, but I liked her arrangement. She's trying something different Simon!
she one fun girl and i cant agree with it more... but she needs to get more control on her voice.. but i like her :D
C'mon!...it wasn't that terrible, I actually enjoyed it a lot!...and the vocals where pretty good, a little shouty, but good...and btw...I'm Sebastian, and I'm new here, just saying hi...hehehe!