Elise Testone – You and I – American Idol 11 Top 7 Video MP3
Elise Testone sang ‘You and I’ on the American Idol 11 Top 7
So much better than Haley Reinhart!
You can vote for Elise Testone by calling 1-866-IDOLS-07 (1-866-436-5707) or Text “VOTE” to 5707
Randy Jackson: This girl is talented. The releases Ah!
Jennifer Lopez: You let go and kept control at the same time. Nobody can sing like you. You’re a closer.
Steven Tyler: You turned into genius.
Watch the video here:
American Idol on YouTube
Listen to the MP3:
Download MP3 here (Right-Click Save Target As…)
Latest News on Elise Testone
All News on Elise Testone
Got Something to Add?
If a song was made for Elise this was it! Great performance for me, and it should definitely keep her around for another week (though with the numbers it is possible she hits bottom three - someone has to).
I wish people would give Elise credit for the lovely melodic changes she did. They were subtle, but if you listen, she really made this her own, but gave credit to the original. Love it! <3
Not Elise's best, but I really liked it. Haley's personality grated on my nerves so much that I had to leave the room when she sang.
Haley's version is better.. she puts alot of emotions in the song.. Elise's version is something like someone talking in long rhymes....
I do love Haley's version, believe me, but Elise's version has a grittier and more passionate fervor that I just get swallowed up in. :)
ok guys i went back to youtube and listened to Haleys version. Not even close Elise was way better. This was anything but karokee. Elise is the real deal
Definitely not better than Haley's version that's for sure. and Lady Gaga actually sings it better in her live performances.
This is really good, but Haley's version is still untouchable (aside from Gaga of course). Gosh, I just remembered how in love I was with Haley. sigh..
I'm the BIGGEST Elise fanboy around and I'll be honest...
This wasn't the Idol moment I was hoping for BUT it was damn close ;)
Seriously, Rickey's taste level - I just can't. This over Haley's? Save Philip Phillips? My god you don't deserve ti recap singing shows.
.....I'm really sorry...but I didn't like it ;_____; I'm trying to find the good things about it but I can't. She went back to many of the things that made her bad like trying to adjust the melody when she just can't. She got shouty to make up for garbling the notes (like Philip) and she didn't handle the song with care except for the first thirty seconds.
"So much better than Haley Reinhart"... okay lets not get crazy here. Elise was good tonight, but I refuse to compare her and Haley.
@vjwilkinson The moment I saw a Haley criticism coming up, I thought the argument was asinine. But seriously, Haley had a lot more charm than Elise does. As for the performance, way glorified.
@bananafries Haley's was relaxed and she was at home on the stage. I felt like Elise had a lot of nerves.
@IdleTime EXACTLY....it's like watching a concert parody of Gaga.....
@takakupo yeah exactly like Lady Gaga....i dont like this too
@takakupo What are u listening to. Thats exactly how the song is suppose to be sung. She was amazing
@bwatt27 I love both versions. They both did a great rendition of this song. :)
@Mikhail XO @jlscott13 No offense, but this was NOT in "Whole Lotta Love" and "Vienna" level. Just glorified and overrated. That praise was more deserved for Haley than Eise. No wonder I have a hard time warming up to her.
@bananafries Contrived is probably a better word. I know it's harsh, but I wouldn't put this in the top rung of performances for the night.
@beachboydave No. No, no, no. I love "You and I" with a passion and Lady Gaga does not shout. She sings the song and the last half of Elise's performance wasn't great. In my opinion, it was a stumble.
@Mikhail XO @Mikhail @jlscott13 Sure, you'd entitled to your opinion, but was the prickish statement to Jessica necessary? And I was only criticizing her performance. But seriously, don't be such an a**hat!