Andrew Garcia – Forever – Video MP3 American Idol Top 10

this stupid download link still doesn't work

He did great, hope he stay.

Oh how I wish he really was "back." If our expectations were too high before, now they're too low. We'll cheer him on for anything that's not out of tune (come to think, he was kinda pitchy here too). Simon's funny, I'm gonna miss him next year. But Usher ROCKS as a mentor.

Hmmmm...I didn't even recognize the song until he got to the chorus. Meh.

honestly speaking, didnt find it great, i definitely don't think hes a bad singer but his voice isn't powerful enough singing live on the big stage, it seems a bit forced and he loses whats great about his voice when hes forcing it.

Super performance from ANDREW! This version is amazing. It makes me wanna dance forever with special someone... Way to go ANDREW! Keep it up!

Oh man he is SO boring. Can´t we get his mom on AI?

I missed the show tonight - the first time since I started watching the show in season 7, boo! But, I see that Andrew really pulled it off again! I'm not a big fan of his - although who wasn't after seeing his brilliant performance of Straight Up - but otherwise, I've really been feeling like he's a one-trick pony until tonight, so sorry I missed it! I have been hoping he'd be voted off, but now it's taken an interesting twist! Kudos to Andrew! I always like to see someone step up!

I am really glad this kid had a good night. He has a very unique recording voice and is actually one of the few kids that does understand who he is as an artist. I'm just not sure his style is going to be able to keep up with some of the others on the show.

nice andrew!!! we love you!!! :)

let me tell you what he needs to do????????? A police Tune....Like walking on the moon or Roxanne ...

GET ON IT!!!!

really good vocals, really good song choice, loved the arrangement, first time i've really enjoyed him i think.

That sounded really off-key and pitchy to me -- I thought it was his worse performance so far, although it did get a bit better toward the end.

He has had a really disappointing run -- at one time early in the competition, I thought he might be a front-runner, but he has had some real stinkers of performances where it was just painful to listen to.

I honestly thought this was much better than the original. I can't stand Chris Brown. He put so much more emotion into this song where Chris put none what so ever. Plus this song sounds sooooooooooooooooo much better acoustic.

This is good. This is what he does best.

Definitely his best performance since Hollywood week. That being said, it was just a'ight for me, dawg.

great arrangement but i really don't like his voice.

that was just so ordinary. something you can hear in a coffee shop or somewhere...

Better than last week but still sort of boring. Simon is right; he's got no personality.

It's not that they don't like him as a singer, they don't like him as competition. He was really good today; thus when people disagree and gives thumbs down to his performance, they're just scared of the fierce competition, usually it's from fans of really bad singers like Tim urban or okay singers like...you decide. But fans of Siobhan and Mamasox and Lee aren't going to bash andrew, because although he's competition, he's not truly yet; maybe consecutive performances will get them frantically disturbed hence the initiation of bashing Andrew from these "normal fans". I'm a fan because of his youtube performances, not because of just his performances; the few good performances still don't drown out the bad ones yet, hopefully 2 more good ones--if he lasts-- will make him a frightening challenger to those normal fans.

This acoustic version sounds even better than the original! Andrew Garcia is an American Idol with a global representation! He is everyman!

It was only a matter of time before he finally had a good performance! This guy is back! At least til disco week LOL

Really nice job. Andrew is BACK!

is it me or is this site filled with andrew haters? either the admin is only approving bad comments about andrew or the people who go to this site all have that in common. I dont see how it was that bad. so fuck off

It's definitely a step up from his past performances. However, I still believed this performance was quite mediocre. Don't get me wrong, I'm definitely Team Andrew Garcia but as a fan, I believe he can do so much better.

Simon dares to call someone boring? He's the first to be boring, starting with his clothes, the tone of his voice...
Andrew did very well.

i like it. go andrew. welcome back!

It's about time Andrew... I liked this!

hhmm how come i can't hear any sound..??

when Simon goes home tonight and hears this back he'll be like OMG that was awful....Im not getting the andrew appeal...he has zero star quality...his voice is generic....and he has no chance of winning!!!

Ok.he prove some male singer also as bad as female singer.we need triple elimination,.this is waste time show now.

I'm still not impressed. The judges are raving this, and it sounded just like his Top 24 performance. I just don't get it. the chorus sounded really breathy too.

There we go. =)

If only he wasn't such a Daney Gokey clone, I may not dislike him as much as I do but I have to be objective.....and that was a great performance.

sweet. finally.

to all of you who gave up on andrew....NOW WHAT...easily the best performance of the night and ANDREW IS BACK! This was awesome.

That was *worse* than Tim. They made no comments about his pitch problems. It was maybe coffee house warm up. He's hopelessly overrated but the judges had PIMP turned up to 11.

WTH Randy loving the outfit? Andrew looked like the guy from Los Lobas during the La Bamba days. DATED.

yes! it was about time Andrew is back since this performance i forgot about that other song he sang from Paula Abdul "up straight" or "straight up" whatever it was called lol, keep it up Andrew!!!! Great Job!!!

only if we can replace you with your little sister

My man, my man....sounds like he's back..I hope he gets through tonight I think he could take off now with a little confidence. If he does get through and pulls another good performance next week he could be the dark horse!