American Idol

American Idol 12 Top 4 – Who’s Going Home? – Poll

Who’s going home on the American Idol 12 Top 4? Who’s your favorite? Take the poll!

The Top 4 take on “one-hit wonders” — which is deceiving because most have been covered by popular artists that have many hits.

But I don’t mind. I love “MacArthur Park”. One of my favorite songs ever.

Who’s Your Favorite?

[polldaddy poll="7060424"]

Who’s Going Home?

[polldaddy poll="7060421"]

The Latest on American Idol 12

All posts on American Idol 12

Follow me on Facebook!Follow me on Google+

American Idol American Idol 12Poll
Showbiz News from our Partners

Got Something to Add?

22 comments
abercrombieco2
abercrombieco2

or the twist is "no one is going home this week and two people are going home next week" move

BenSwanson
BenSwanson

no one goes home. they wont use the save though, they cant. they will make something up

BenSwanson
BenSwanson

Umm why do people think Kree is plus size. she looks great to me

Samson58
Samson58

they were throwing kree under the bus yesterday... so if anyone goes it will be her.. they overpraise of the other 3 is sickening..candace is the best one but you never know,, i think they are trying for an amber/angie finale...kree was upset when nikki bashed her,, how hard is it to sing after that,,, yet she sounded beautiful on a whiter shade of pale.. they were just contriving the show to get her elimianted.. and so dissapointed in keith last night...

jbeee
jbeee

I thought Angie was the strongest followed by Candace. I think there duet actually helped them both, rather than took away from their solo performances. While I thought Amber's first number was fairly strong there were some notes that she strained...and MacArthur Park was not good. I have to believe in private Randy goes back and watches the playback and cringes when he sees how much they are fawning over her. Kree wasn't weak, but her performances didn't have the impact of the other performances. They were really quite solid, just not a lot of fireworks to them. Frankly, last night, I felt more like I was watching a concert or variety show than watching a competition. All of them can be solid singers with the right songs.

realGary
realGary

Update: "No one" in the who is going home poll has 20% of the vote and is gaining on the other two contestants. Will "No one" win?

takakupo
takakupo

Oh, geez. Who the hell keeps voting for Angie? She has been middling all year long, and has not done anything close to stunning, especially during the latter half of the season. 

She's going to be another middling winner -__-; 

AdrianS
AdrianS

I really hope Candice does not go home she have not had a good week or at least not her best but she definitly wasn't the worst.

Rickey
Rickey moderator

Added "no one"

realGary
realGary

Yes, we need a no one option

abercrombieco2
abercrombieco2

no one , the twist will be since the save wasn't used last week they can use it this week if they want. 

realGary
realGary

@jbeee Good summary! Especially about Randy. I admit to going back and watching replays and reassess my point of view as well. Enjoying music  from quality performers pleases audiences and sells. As to Randy? Hm better leave that alone.

It was like a concert show to me as well.

abercrombieco2
abercrombieco2

@Mikhail XO this whole season has been boring imo , and i find my self bored watching the show.   but face it the show pretty much did it to its self by forcing a female winner on us.   do you think their would have been a female winner if they let threw the better male singers instead of kicking them out in earlier rounds?

KatManFoSho
KatManFoSho

@Mikhail XO - You're such a child!  Although I agree the judging panel is definitely assaulting the plus-size girls (doesn't take a mental giant to figure that out), it has nothing to do with Amber.  Your comment is once again totally uncalled for.

takakupo
takakupo

I will say though, Angie was the only one with an overall good performance last night that didn't miss a note and wasn't boring ("Cry me a River"). 

Will be interesting to see who goes home tomorrow. 

joeytad2010
joeytad2010

@Rickey YUP! They mentioned a twist because they have an extra week for not using the save so now they will jump the shark by eliminating no one.  (And thus save their annointed one in Amber) 

 They will combine this week's vote and next week's.  It has been done before.  Check the FOX schedule, it says the Final 4 will perform AGAIN for your votes.

takakupo
takakupo

@abercrombieco2 Nah, I think they'll just do some kind of Idol gives back or some kind of special. They'll give out commemorative semi-finals contestant plates as a prize. 

AdrianS
AdrianS

Yes. The guys were all pretty meh to begin with. There were some great male singers that would've made it to the top 5 but they weren't gonna win.