American Idol

American Idol 11 – Top 3 Perform – Live Blog Recap

Tonight, the Top 3 of American Idol 11 take on three songs each: Jimmy’s choice, judges’ choice and their choice. So much music! Jessica Sanchez, Joshua Ledet and Phillip Phillips battle it out to see who will make the finale next week.

You can check out the song spoilers HERE.

Don’t forget to join the Office Pool as well as the side office pool down the right side of the blog.

Note: If the live blog isn’t updating with new information, please delete cookies for the Rickey.org domain in your browser.

I’m not gonna hide my excitement for tonight any longer. AHHH! I just hope that Jessica comes out swinging tonight. She needs a wow moment to guarantee her spot in next week’s finale. Is it really that time already?!

Anyways, I will be live blogging the events of the night right here. Come back soon and often to check out my thoughts on the talent. Fingers crossed for Jessica!

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

“Who will make the finale?”

Note: Jessica looks amazing tonight.

 

JUDGES CHOICE

Joshua Ledet - “I’d Rather Go Blind” by Etta James – (Picked by Randy)

One of my all time favorite songs! Too predictable? Yea, just a little bit. He looks rather dashing tonight in a black suit with a red rose. He’s sounded pretty good tonight. He’s caressing his falsetto a bit. Showing restraint is always a good thing, Joshua. Midway through, he picks it up and throws the song on the ground. Admittedly, this was pretty good, but Rachel Crow on The X-Factor OWNS this song.

ANOTHER STANDING OVATION!!! Who saw that coming, huh?

Check out his full performance HERE.

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

Jessica Sanchez - “My All” by Mariah Carey (Picked by Jennifer Lopez )

LOVE THIS SONG! She’s definitely showing a more tender side to her vocals. This song takes so much restraint to handle. Pretty impressive for a 16-year-old. Some of her lower notes are a bit wobbly. Maybe they should have taken the song up a few steps? This was definitely one of her best performances, in my book. Based on vocals alone, she should make the finale. :) (Note: I am now a fanboy)

Randy thought it was absolutely beautiful. He called it one of the best times a Mariah song has ever been covered. Steven said she was the winner. (I predict he’ll forget and tells someone else the same thing)

Check out her full performance HERE.

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

Phillip Phillips - “Beggin’” by Madcon (Picked by Steven)

Huh. Interesting. I would never have thought he would sing this. He’s broken out his guitar for a sparse arrangement. Well, not for long. Before we know it, the full band kicks in. It’s lost some of that magic from the beginning. He should have stripped the song down completely.  Eh, not one of his best performances. His “Volcano” from last week was a million times better.

J.Lo said it was GREAT. Steven hopes he writes his own material. Randy: “We were just at a Phil Phillips concert.”

Check out his full performance HERE.

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

Round 1:

Randy said Joshua had the slight edge

J.Lo gave props to PP

Steven is on the fence

 

Jason says: Round 1 goes to Jessica/Joshua.

 

CONTESTANTS CHOICE

Joshua Ledet - “Imagine” by John Lennon

LOVE THIS SONG! But it’s been done to death on this show. David Archuleta OWNS this song. Just saying. He’s holding back his vocals, which is nice. Midway through, he adds in this screechy wail. There was something off about it though. Not my favorite performance from him.

Steven thought it was beautiful (does he not know any other words?). J.lo loved his restrained take on the song.

Check out his full performance HERE.

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

Jessica Sanchez - “I Don’t Wanna Miss a Thing” by Aerosmith

Oh, this song. She’s doing something very different than I would have expected. There is a string arrangement that’s quite nice. I wouldn’t have picked this song, personally. Allison Iraheta OWNS this song. I’ll be honest: Vocally, this is great, but there is something missing from it? Not quite sure. Pretty good, though. It sat there a little too long for me, but she nailed the ending note! VOTE FOR HER. ;)

Steven thought she took a great song and made it greater! J.Lo loved her last note.  Randy thought she delivered a big moment.

Check out her full performance HERE.

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

Phillip Phillips - “Disease” by Matchbox Twenty

I grew up listening to this band. Love this song. This is a nice chill performance, but I’m not sure most of the younger generations will connect to it. But really, does that even matter at this point? This is much better than his first performance. Dare I say, a little sexy? Bonus: The blonde saxophone player is back!

J.lo didn’t feel like it was a wow performance. Steven said it was a PP performance.

Check out his full performance HERE.

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

Jason says: Round 2 goes to PP

 

JIMMY’S CHOICE

Joshua Ledet - “No More Drama” by Mary J. Blige

OH. Yes. The song starts out with just a piano. OMG. His shoulders are bedazzled!!! Am I becoming a Joshua fan? Because I’m really diggin’ this. Am I sick? Towards the end, he brings the flavor, and it’s far less annoying than usual. He then RIPS off his jacket. He’s really gettin’ into the song. Best of the night (so far)? Yup.

J.lo said he had a “perfect marriage” of control and letting go. Magic! (Um, she might not be the right person to give advice about a “perfect marriage.” #JustSaying)

Check out his full performance HERE.

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

Jessica Sanchez - “I’ll Be There” by the Jackson 5

Oh man. This song? I can’t. Why would Jimmy pick such an old song for her? Forget his blabber about the youth and whatnot. However, Jessica sounds pretty great on this. (Can you tell I want her to win, yet?) She shows restraint (I’m getting tired of this word) and power on the bigger parts of the song, especially towards the end. The arrangement is rather sleepy, but I blame that on Jimmy. Ugh. Are they sabotaging this girl?!?!?! VOTE!

J.lo thought she killed it so hard at the end. Steven loved it (was there ever any doubt?). It was just OK for Randy.

Check out her full performance HERE.

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

Phillip Phillips - “We’ve Got Tonight” by Bob Seger

Good song. He starts on a stool with stars dangling above his head. Simple piano. This is actually pretty good. It’s tender and sweet — something we haven’t seen much from him. There are a few moments that seemed off or that he was straining, but I thought this was the perfect choice for him. One of his best performances of the competition, for sure.

STANDING OVATION!!! I wonder who they want in the finale?!?!

Check out his full performance HERE.

Photo Credit: American Idol/FOX

 

Jason Says: Round 3 goes to Joshua

 

Best Performances of the Night:

Jessica’s “My All”

Joshua’s “No More Drama”

 

Finale Should Be: Jessica/Joshua

Finale Will Be: Joshua/Phillip

 

 

That’s a wrap, folks! Next week is the finale, and after the judges’ performance tonight, I don’t see how a Joshua/PP finale won’t happen. They bot got standing O’s, and Jessica was given some pretty lame song choices. It was obvious that they steam rolled Jessica tonight. Oy.

Can a girl win this show?

 

NOTE: For those that believe in conspiracy theories, the Kristy Lee Cook Curse applies to PP (he’s from Leesburg, GA).

 

What did you guys think of the night? What was the best performance? Worst performance?

Follow me on Twitter! • Follow me on Facebook! • Follow me on Pinterest!

American Idol
Showbiz News from our Partners

Got Something to Add?

345 comments
yhingnaz
yhingnaz

No offense to the American Idol judges  Philip is NOT a versatile Singer!!! come on! he is just an Ordinary good looking singer an additional to a bunch! come on!

jepoy
jepoy

Round 1 - Jessica

Round 2 - P2

Round 3 - Josh

 

This was a boring performance night. The finalist all looked tired. But the show must go on. They each showed what they were made of. Based on all three rounds I think we'll have a Joshua-Phillip Finale. As much as I love Jessica, she just underwhelmed tonight (*she's sick I know)

DenniesSiongco
DenniesSiongco

Its a J & J finale! Joshua and Jessica, for the first time in recent years that we will have an ALL GIRL FINALE hahaha!

jargarbo
jargarbo

I think all of them showed vulnerability with the song choices and the way they performed it as well. It leaves us guessing who's who. But one thing for sure... P2 will sail easily that's just my guess. But I'm hoping that Jessica will sail through and it wont matter to me anymore who will be with Jessica in top 2 as long as Jessica will be there.

myjhere
myjhere

Jessica and Phillip for the Finale..

 

DAMN Sabotage on Jessica >.<

DenniesSiongco
DenniesSiongco

They threw Jessica under the bus!  Boo!  Shame on you Randy!

kexzy01
kexzy01

booooo!! sabotaging Jessica... boooo JIMMY!!!!

amor825
amor825

It's going to be a girl and a boy in the final.  Count Joshua as a girl. LOL!

ashnazg792
ashnazg792

They clearly don't have enough lines open tonight. I can't get through for anyone. I'm wondering why they didn't open two lines for each contestant.

KevinOngsiapco
KevinOngsiapco

JESSICA JESSICA JESSICA! We want a girl in the finale!

ArchieSue
ArchieSue

It will be a Mantasia/PP finale!!! Yes it will !  Bye bye Jess. She didn't connect tonight like the other two.

Mantasia FTW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

wildhorse19
wildhorse19

Let's vote now! please don't vote for Joshua.

mwk89
mwk89

I'll be throwing some votes to jessica, mainly because 2007 was the last time we've had a female winner. Think about it, Jordan Sparks Season 7…that's many many moons ago

Joystickenvy
Joystickenvy

on the replay of the aerosmith song jessica really sounds sharp, a bit on the mike j. song too.  not that it matters to people who vote :>

jepoy
jepoy

it's gonna be a Joshua-P2 Finale. Danggit.

Feel bad for Jessica. It's okay li'l one... I'm sure you'll have a career after Idol!

wildhorse19
wildhorse19

I think is going to be Phillip vs Jessica.

mwk89
mwk89

So its still wide open, but I'm just hoping for something that leaves a female in the finale

myjhere
myjhere

I'm missing the "GROWL" :(((.. but Jessica for the win! xD

Joystickenvy
Joystickenvy

p2 was winning the night by a lot through the first two songs (not saying he sang the best just did the best at what he does compared to the other two), but that third song was very weak.  regardless I think p2 cruises to the finale. toss up between the two girls

joshy
joshy

It's pretty evident that Jessica struggles so much because of her sore throat. But hey, even with that she did great. clap! clap!

mwk89
mwk89

And now the over-pimping, ugh

Joystickenvy
Joystickenvy

i think i understand why p2 doesn't sing in his natural voice now.  it's pretty weak.  apparently the gruntly growly thing is all he's got going for him

ArchieSue
ArchieSue

Just speaking the truth.  Jessica is a great vocalist but I didn't connect with her at all. She didn't move me. lols  The song choices for her were terrible!  The closes to a girl winning is Mantasia. Sorry guys!  If Skylar, Elise, Erica and Hollie can't win, how can Jessica who sang tonight with no emotions at all. Just my opinion of course. 

laff
laff

 @ArchieSue Mmmm, I'm thinking my Joshua is a goner. Not his best night, although No More Drama was fab. Jessica played it safe, so I think she's in with Phil. :( sad to see my man leave, but I'm prepared.

mwk89
mwk89

scratch that, Season 6…even further

laff
laff

 @jepoy Josh is the only one who got all positive critiques. I think Jessica;s fans will save her. Phil has always been a shoo-in, so doesn't matter.  I fear Josh is the vulnerable one.

 

ArchieSue
ArchieSue

 @Joystickenvy OMG I kind of like that.  He look kinda cute too with the lighting, lols.  WGWG is going to win again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ashnazg792
ashnazg792

 @mwk89 Oh, thank you. I had no idea - I just follow on the blog here, and the blog only listed one for each.

ArchieSue
ArchieSue

 @laff Have hope for Joshua, he connected a lot better than Jess but he did get red lights, lols.  :)

mwk89
mwk89

right year, wrong season

mwk89
mwk89

 @ashnazg792 Joshua is 01, 04, 07. Jessica 02, 05, 08, PP 03, 06, 09

ArchieSue
ArchieSue

 @laff Lols!!!! Hey remember he is Mantasia!  He can win!  This can happen again. :) 

laff
laff

 @ArchieSue I love him like I haven't loved anyone since Cook. But I fear he's too "screamy" for the white conservative Idol-watching public.